Karen Grant, Reforesting Scotland and the Thousand Huts campaign, updates us on new policy, new legislation and a whole new movement of hutters.

Inshriach Bothy, designed by Iain Macleod and Bobby Niven.
Reforesting Scotland’s Thousand Huts campaign has come a long way since its launch in 2011. The campaign was founded to remove the barriers to achieving a dream shared by so many: that of having a small, simple hut from which to enjoy the peace and beauty of the natural world. Once barriers in policy and regulations were removed, the campaign aimed to help a new hutting movement to flourish.
As readers will know, huts were included in Scottish Planning Policy in 2014 – and two years later, there followed a public consultation on huts in relation to building regulations. The response was greatly in favour of simplifying the process for huts, ensuring that more of the responsibility is passed to the hutter (rather than Building Control officers).
To do this, the Scottish Government created a new building type, 23A in Schedule 3 of the Building Regulations, which applies to huts. In effect, it exempts huts from many building regulations except for some key areas including structure, stoves, barriers and underground drainage (drainage is one of the aspects which will still require a warrant). While the hut builder will be required by law to comply with the regulations in these non-exempt areas, in most cases they will not be required to get a Building Warrant. Not only will this reduce the burden on hutters, it will also reduce the burden on building standards officers, saving money for local authorities.
Resources to help those wishing to build one or more huts
The Scottish Planning Policy includes encouragement for planning authorities to consider huts for recreational use, and includes a definition of a hut. In support of this policy, Reforesting Scotland’s Thousand Huts campaign has published the guidance paper New hutting developments: Good practice guidance on the planning, development and management of huts and hut sites, which can be used to help applicants or planners considering new hut developments.
To help hut builders navigate the new building type for huts in relation to building regulations, Reforesting Scotland is producing a guide, ‘The Good Practice Guide to Hut Construction‘. One of its writers, Peter Caunt, explains, “It will be the hut owner’s responsibility to ensure they comply with high standards of health and safety, and low environmental impact. Some areas, such as underground drainage, will still require a Building Warrant, whereas in other areas, such as structure, the responsibility is theirs to comply with the relevant regulations. If they don’t comply, they will be liable if something goes wrong.” To make sure you are notified when this guide is ready, join our mailing list at www.thousandhuts.org.
We have also produced a Voluntary Code of Good Practice for Hutters and Landlords to help people develop a fair formal agreement between those who have a hut and those who own the land the hut sits on.
A pilot hut site in Fife
Over the last few years, the campaign has also been working with Forest Enterprise Scotland to develop a pilot hut site on public forest land. After several years of navigating this complex process with the various stakeholders, an application was made to Fife Council Planning Department. In June 2017 the site at Carnock Woods achieved planning permission, and the allocation process has now begun for this site.
The growing hutting movement
During the last few years, the Thousand Huts campaign has flourished into a lively community of hutters, prospective hutters, builders, foresters, planners, artists and dreamers. The enormously successful annual Hutters’ Rally has continued to expand in size – and each year it has sold out. The facebook group has over 5700 members, there are almost 1000 Twitter followers, and an emailing list of 2300. At our recent Hutters’ Rally, planning consultant Richard Heggie presented a map of many hut site planning applications he is involved in – and there are many more. Media coverage has been plentiful, including BBC TV, Radio Scotland, the Times, the Herald and the Scotsman and more. Interest in huts is vast – and is growing stronger. Our challenge now is to support more people to achieve the dream of a simple hut in the woods.
If you would like more information about any aspect of hutting, please contact us at huts@reforestingscotland.org, or join our mailing list at www.thousandhuts.org or join us on Facebook or on Twitter @thousandhuts
BACK
Celia Sweeney, Equalities Manager with Historic Environment Scotland, shares the discussion and insights from BEFS Diversity in Public Boards event on 20th February 2018.
This event was perfectly timed as it followed the success of the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Bill. The effect of which will be to create a statutory gender representation objective for Scottish public boards.
The three speakers: Beltus Etchu Ojong (Next Step Initiative); Talat Yaqoob (Equate Scotland and 50:50 Campaign) and Jane Ryder (Historic Environment Scotland) are all practiced Board Members or Chairs and were invited to offer their individual perspectives.
The Speakers
Beltus Etchu Ojong began the panel conversation highlighting the lack of visible diversity from within the African community on Boards and in employment, and shared the experience of the African Tenants Forum, which created a route for the community to access information and be able to influence decision making. In terms of employment, he talked about the Next Step Initiative, which is a positive action training programme to create routes into employment where there is under-representation from the Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic community.
Talat Yaqoob continued the panel conversation highlighting the work of Equate Scotland to encourage women in the Science, Technology and Built Environment sectors. Examples of support highlighted included the creation of a women student network as well as CPD for women working in the sectors. Progress has been made in civil engineering and she is keen to understand the why and how this is working, in order to share learning across other sectors; so perhaps opportunities for specific sector research to uncover the learning from this change. Talat is also Chair of the 50:50 campaign and for her, the Bill provides for more outreach in order to create ‘routes to widen the participation on Boards’. It also places a responsibility on Boards to influence the structural and other factors which can prevent people from coming forward. She stressed the importance of intersectionality; women are not a homogenous group. Women are shaped by influences arising from age; disability, sexual orientation and socio-economic experience and therefore it is important to look at all women. Talat talked about the unintended consequences which can arise for businesses, which fail to take into account women’s issues/needs. She also emphasised the positive business case, leading to better decision making, business improvement and positive reputation.
Jane Ryder wound up the panel conversation by extending the definition of diversity to that of considering the need to have an effective Board, which was able to demonstrate the necessary skills footprint as well as providing a vehicle for different voices/views and perspectives. There is a need for Boards to be conscious about all-round views and how to get them. Some of the barriers to inclusion were practical and she cited the lack of hearing induction loop facilities; the timing of meetings, which create difficulties for widening the demographic, and the need for support structures to create a talent pipeline. By way of example, Jane cited the initiative between the Scottish Government and Standard Life, which HES is engaged with and supports the opportunities for women to be co-opted onto a Board Committee to gain experience and insight into Board functions.
The Discussion
Many of the audience questions pointed to potential activity which should be considered to promote more involvement. I’ve highlighted a few to offer a flavour of the discussion.
Board Meetings often take place in the day and/or evening – one questioner suggested employers being encouraged to release people during the day. This made me think about Corporate Social Responsibility, which is often linked to employer’s charitable support or encouraging volunteering, and perhaps this could be a vehicle through which employees could be supported, who are interested in sharing their skills and developing new ones within the context of a civic society.
Using language and changing the narrative to attract people to apply for positions – the questioner shared their experience of using positive equal opportunities language in advertising, which had the effect of broadening and enhancing the interest from a wider pool of people. This was a useful reminder that language can attract as well as detract.
Communication style – here the panel replied to the questioner on a number of levels. From the role of the Chair, it is important to illicit ‘all round’ views and to be skilled in ways to achieve this across the Board. Panel members shared the importance of ‘being heard’ and managing ‘intellectual theft’; as illustrated by the cartoon. Written communication is a format where all the speakers acknowledged that there is a heavy emphasis and that part of the role involves significant reading and preparation for meetings.
Board outreach – the panel acknowledged that one of the effects of the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Bill will be to encourage more outreach and Boards to get involved in creating ways for this to happen. This touched on earlier references from the speakers on forums/advisory panels presenting opportunities as a talent pipeline. There was a sense too that such forums/advisory panels helped to demystify what happens at a Board and what is involved in being part of a Board.
Having the right Skills – this is important as many Boards may look for specific skills e.g. Financial, Performance and/or People Management, or they may be looking for broader skills e.g. leadership; taking strategic direction. It is important not to allow ‘unconscious bias’ to shape the view of what and who makes a leader. Bias should not influence any assessment of competence and ability as women from minority ethnic; disabled and LGBT+ communities don’t lack the relevant qualifications, experience and aspiration to sit on boards. Understanding and recognizing that we all have bias is important and consciously challenging ourselves contributes to fair decision making and influencing change.
In the closing remarks, an observation was made on the audience profile; there were significantly more women than men in attendance. This chimes with similar discussions on encouraging women in senior workplace positions; the curiosity and interest outweighed the audience in favour of women there too. This is changing however, from a discussion which recognises that diversity is the right thing to do, to one which knows it is good for business and the opportunities it brings to learn and grow from others, to ensure all round views are captured, to enhance decision making. It fills the talent gap as well as being good for society as a whole and creates the visibility for more women to come forward knowing their voices are encouraged. Lessons and learning which translates across into public boards and the wider civic society sphere.
There has undoubtedly been a ‘big conversation’ leading up to the Gender Representation on Public Boards (Scotland) Bill and this conversation now needs to move within public boards. The research and available data tell us that there is still a way to go, which is why the 50:50 objective is needed to stimulate action.
Measuring where we are with where we want to be will resonate with the new millennial generation, who are tuned into the values of equality, diversity and inclusion as an important part of their employment choices. There is a growing expectation that this is mirrored in other business, life and social interests. Having a focus on equality, diversity, inclusion and fair representation seems to me to be the cornerstone for organisations who want to make sure that they continue to grow and meet the needs of their diverse customers, stakeholders and partners.
BACK
Erin Fulton, Volunteer Manager, PAS, introduces PAS’ new youth volunteering initiative and PAS Youth Volunteer Award.
On the 25th of January PAS launched their exciting new youth volunteering initiative to encourage young people to take the lead as active citizens in their local communities in the Year of Young People.
We were pleased to have Kevin Stewart MSP, Scottish Minister for Local Government and Housing introduce the new programme and its associated award, which will help shape a young volunteer’s journey. The programme is aimed at young people aged 16-25 years old and will empower Youth Volunteers to be influencers and agents of change, actively participating in the decision-making processes in their local communities.
Young volunteers will work towards the PAS Youth Volunteer Award, with the potential to earn Young Scot Card Rewards, which involves completing ten hours of volunteering in areas matched to their interests and skills.
Speaking at the launch event, the Chair of PAS, Irene Beautyman, said:
“The launch of PAS’ Youth Volunteer Programme and Award is a landmark moment in PAS’ 25 year history. Our role is to enable communities to have their voices heard in the planning system by empowering them to become active citizens, through education and advice, awareness raising, and facilitating positive dialogue.
The places in which we live, work, access public services, build our relationships, and generally live our lives, are crucial to our physical, mental, social and economic wellbeing. Therefore, the way in which we plan our places, and the extent to which we bring people together, is vital for Scotland’s overall social and economic wellbeing.
As our present and future generation, Scotland’s young people are crucial to creating great places, and it is vital their voices are heard. In the Year of Young People 2018, our Youth Volunteering Programme and Award is an important step in helping create a Scotland where young people feel empowered to be active citizens in their local communities.”
Minister for Local Government and Housing, Kevin Stewart MSP, said:
“2018 has been designated as the Year of Young People, the first themed year to recognise people as one of Scotland’s greatest assets. And following the work of the independent planning review we will see the passage of a Planning Bill through Parliament. It is therefore auspicious that this volunteering programme is being launched at this time.
“I look forward to hearing about the how the PAS Youth Volunteers have benefitted from their experience. It will indeed be a positive one if they can build upon the skills, expertise and commitment of the current volunteers and staff. And I am also keen to hear about examples where the Youth Volunteers are making an impact in their communities.”
Current PAS volunteer, Melissa Shields, 19, said:
“It is especially important during the Year of Young people that the voices of the future generation are heard in key decisions about our local communities. Young volunteers are an incredibly powerful way to inspire and encourage participation amongst other young people because of the peer-to-peer relationship.
I have immensely enjoyed my volunteering with PAS to date, and found it to be a very rewarding experience. I would really urge other young people to sign up to the PAS Youth Volunteer Programme and Award as a way of really making a difference in their local community as well as developing new skills and gaining valuable experience.”
The Year of Young People 2018 is an opportunity for everybody in Scotland to come together and celebrate the contribution of our young people, enabling young people to have a stronger voice on issues which affect their lives and increasing the visibility of young people in the decisions that shape our future. The Year of Young People 2018 is the right time to launch our new Youth Volunteer programme.
As PAS approaches its 25th anniversary of helping people to shape the decisions that affect them and their communities, the launch of the Youth Volunteer programme is an important development in how the organisation supports communities across Scotland.
Over the last 25 years, our volunteer network has been made up of built environment professionals, mainly planners, architects and designers. Through the Youth Volunteer programme, our volunteer network will expand to include young people. The Youth Volunteer programme will promote active citizenship and encourage young people to be actively involved in placemaking.
Our vision is for a Scotland which creates great places in which all communities, whether urban, rural or island, can take pride, and feel empowered to shape. The decisions made now will affect young people the longest and therefore we feel it is crucial that they are included in the process. We hope that being introduced in the placemaking agenda early on, our youth volunteers will feel empowered to be engaged throughout their lives.
Erin Fulton, Volunteer Manager, PAS
BACK
Isobel Leckie, Causey Development Trust, tells us about the work of the Trust and the design for transforming The Causey.
Background
Edinburgh – already a compact and walkable city – could also be a European exemplar of a city that is designed to be pedestrian and cycle friendly. However, in fact it is one of the least pedestrianised cities in Europe, and still has a long way to go to catch with cities such as Copenhagen and Amsterdam in terms of cycling and walking provision. The Causey project seeks to address this and contribute to turning Edinburgh into this European exemplar!
Causey Development Trust (CDT), a volunteer-led charity has been working for 10 years to transform a historic, car-dominated street, West Crosscauseway, (known locally as “The Causey”), into a place that prioritises people before motor vehicles. This involves creating a new public space out of the distinctive, but currently redundant, triangular traffic island space, and re-configure how pedestrians, cyclists and motor vehicles will use the space.
On the border of the World Heritage site and at the heart of the Southside Conservation area, CDT intends to create an accessible, beautiful and high-quality public space, promoting walking and cycling, which everyone can enjoy and could also host community and art events.
Community engagement
The project has been based around community engagement from the outset, and the design brief for the site was derived from the aspirations of local people as expressed through a series of “Ideas Workshops” held in 2008-9, as well as exhibitions and events. The more detailed concept design for a people-friendly place was developed by Ironside Farrar in conjunction with a client team including CDT representatives, City of Edinburgh Council, Sustrans Scotland, Edinburgh World Heritage and Living Streets Scotland.
CDT has maintained interest in the concept of a people–friendly space by hosting events, most notably the Southsiders: Portrait of a Community project for which local photographer Peter Dibdin photographed 32 portraits of Southside people. Nine life-sized prints were displayed in and around The Causey. Sorcha Carey, Director of the Edinburgh International Festival, is one of CDT’s patrons and we believe The Causey could become a place for art installations, as well community celebrations and even markets.
Design proposal
A design for transforming The Causey is currently submitted to City of Edinburgh Council (CEC) and has recently progressed to the statutory public consultation stage in a Traffic Regulation Order.
The current proposal is a revision of an earlier design submitted to CEC in 2016 which involved closing West Crosscauseway to through traffic. This initial design proposal – which closed off WCC to through traffic – however, met with concerns from some local residents and stakeholders, particularly around the use of a shared space concept, parking and waste vehicles turning in WCC. The current design seeks to address these concerns in a positive and beneficial manner by maintaining through traffic (although in a West-East direction -the opposite direction to currently) and with the intention that strong traffic-calming measures will be introduced at the subsequent detailed design stage. Two-way cycle traffic on West Crosscauseway and the original vision of a new, accessible and beautiful public space are maintained.
For more details about the proposal, process and how you can support CDT’s work please visit our website and comment on the Traffic Order at trafficorders@edinburgh.gov.uk
With no material objections to the TRO capital works could begin in 2018 and fundraising for this work will continue in earnest by CDT. Sustrans Scotland’s Community Links programme will match-fund what we raise and currently we’re at 50% of an estimated £1.6m. We already have funding pledges from Sustrans, Edinburgh World Heritage, University of Edinburgh, City of Edinburgh Council and Central Scotland Green Network.
Can you help us fund this amazing design and transformation? Do you know of sources of funding for public realm capital works? If so please contact us at info@thecausey.org
Follow us on Twitter @The_Causey
BACK
Niall Murphy, Planning Convener of Pollokshields Community Council, Chair of Pollokshields Heritage & Vice Chair of Pollokshields Trust reflects on the motivations behind a community-led charrette and the challenges arising out of it.
Pollokshields, on Glasgow’s Southside, is the largest Victorian Garden Suburb in Scotland. It was feued in 1848 by Edinburgh Architect David Rhind on behalf of the Maxwell family who owned neighbouring Pollok Estate, with the family guiding its development for six decades.
Rhind’s plan split the suburb into two halves: West Pollokshields, with leafy avenues of large villas and East Pollokshields, with gridded blocks of sandstone tenements. Conscious of the appalling urban conditions in Glasgow at the time, the family insisted on broad streets and a 3-storey datum for tenements to ensure residents had good daylight and air. Flats incorporated bathrooms from the outset – well in advance of various Police Acts.
Today, East Pollokshields is the most multi-cultural area in Scotland with a BME population share of 52%. Between 2001-2013 the population rose by 16%. More than a quarter of households are overcrowded, 33% of children live in poverty, 93.5% of people live within 500m of vacant or derelict land while East Pollokshields has one of the lowest SIMD (Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation) ranks in Scotland.
Though East Pollokshields became a conservation area in 1973 the Victorian tenements are aging and difficult to heat, while the mix of tenures and refuse issues means problems which resulted in the creation of the ‘Enhanced Enforcement Area’ in neighbouring Govanhill, also occurs here.
To help combat these issues in December 2014, Pollokshields Community Council, with support from our MSP, MP and local councillors, obtained agreement from Glasgow City Council that if we secured funding under the SSCI Charrette Mainstreaming Programme they would support us in the preparation of a planning study for the area – something which had been Glasgow City Council policy since the adoption of the City Plan 2 in 2008.
In February 2016, having obtained these funds, augmented by monies from Glasgow City Council, local businesses and amenity societies, we held the ‘Make Your Mark’ East Pollokshields and Port Eglinton Charrette – the first community led charrette in Glasgow – having recruited a consultant team led by Collective Architects.
The key objectives of our brief were how we could make the area a better place to live, to promote the contextual development of the large brownfield sites between Pollokshields and Glasgow city centre, so severance could be reduced and, most importantly, to ensure the charrette report was adopted.
The charrette outcomes were reported at a well-attended community meeting in late March 2016 with the vision publicly endorsed by Nicola Sturgeon MSP and Alison Thewliss MP. The finalised report was lodged with Glasgow City Council for their consideration in June 2016.
Since then, despite plenty of effort including the setting up of the Pollokshields Trust as a community anchor organisation to steer the vision forwards, repeated pre-application engagement with developers of the large brownfield sites to encourage them to take on board the charrette’s design code, to our frustration adoption by Glasgow City Council has still to occur.
Unfortunately, we are not unique. How to get community led charrettes adopted into policy by councils does seem to be the Achilles Heel of the process with the risk of thwarting community enthusiasm which could descend into cynicism and distrust – something sadly flagged up by the survey results for Barriers to Community Engagement in Planning – thereby undermining the efforts of the Scottish Government towards Local Place Plans.
Nevertheless, if we’ve learned anything it is tenacity! Therefore, we welcome a positive overture from Glasgow City Council, at a recent meeting hosted by Nicola Sturgeon MSP, to work collaboratively with us and the Scottish Government on a pilot scheme to ensure that community led charrettes can slot into the development plan process. Will we succeed? Watch this space…
BACK
Bill Pagan, Board member of BEFS, and founding Board member of Cupar Development Trust, offers thoughts on progress in Cupar in 2017 and the challenges to achieving action on the ground.

St Catherine Street from the east, autumn 2017. Completed County Buildings on the left.
Under scaffolding, former Clydesdale Bank on the right, and Burgh Chambers back left, both now completed.
The 2016 CharrettePlus in Cupar, led by PAS, was community-driven and mobilised local businesses, property-owners and the community at large. Many aspirations were identified.
The major tasks of Cupar Development Trust (CDT) in delivering some of the aspirations expressed during the Charrette have not been helped by closures – of another bank, a major office employer, and shops – during 2017. One of the shops explained its closure specifically as a chance to save costs by moving online only, and I believe another is moving in that direction. BEFS Small Towns Reports (including Cupar’s) recognised these sorts of challenges across Scotland.
Nevertheless, Fife Historic Buildings Trust are delivering the CARS and THI schemes, with Fiona Stenke their weel kent representative on the ground. Buildings in the heart of the town centre have been conserved and smartened. A particularly welcome part of the CARS/THI work in 2017 was the conservation of the Burgh Chambers.
The Interpretive Plan, produced in June 2017, after considerable effort by both a local Working Group and CMC Consultants, was the highlight of the year. It was funded by a £15,000 grant from the Scottish Government’s Activating Ideas Fund. The Plan’s main aims are:
- to encourage and define practical steps which will help people engage with Cupar’s rich heritage
- to map the strategic, longer-term goals of the community in ways that policymakers and funders can back.
In the second half of 2017, CDT then made several applications for funding to take the Interpretive Plan forward, with disappointing results. The thrust of these applications was to assist the delivery of “Digital Cupar”, the means identified for enhancing the understanding of Cupar’s Heritage, and increasing footfall in the town centre – both for direct Commercial & Retail activity and for Tourist Interpretation
Another funding application, to the Heritage Enterprise Fund, was for ‘Development Funding’ as a first step to securing capital grant for the renovation of a group of derelict buildings, in the very heart of the town centre. The “Inner Court” project is an important plank of Cupar’s re-generation, and was presented to the Charrette, where it received overwhelming support. Its aims are to deliver 28 new houses, and an element of Community and Commercial facilities, in the backlands bounded by two of Cupar’s main streets, Bonnygate and Crossgate.
This retail development is bound to have some impact on Cupar’s town centre, if indeed there is a market for it – it appears that only one site within it has been let so far.
The main task for CDT in 2018 is to show HLF and others that it is a resilient community-based organisation, with a long-life strategy for delivery. As well as keeping the pot boiling on the Interpretive Plan, the major challenges are the Inner Court Development and George Inn Pend. The overall aspiration is shown in this drawing of Inner Court, George Inn Pend being the one parallel to, and closest to, Bonnygate. The Bonnygate gap site – Cupar’s missing tooth – is shown filled by the only part of the proposals which reaches right through to a main street, the Bonnygate.
CDT’s tasks and aspirations move at a measured pace, dictated by the need for funding. Meantime, other changes intervene. Kingdom Housing Association (who are taking the lead in the Inner Court project) have 49 affordable houses under construction in their Pitscotttie Road site on the south-east boundary; Stephens have lodged a detailed application for 55 mixed housing units, possibly rising to 168, at Gilliesfaulds at the western gateway to the town; and discussions continue on the “Cupar North” site for 1480 houses, with a promised town relief road.
Cupar North has now been included in the Fife Plan. One of the town’s very active groups, Sustainable Cupar, will press for improved road safety provision on the present and future routes to the local services, including schools.
Cupar, like the rest of the country, cannot escape the impact of the financial crash of 2007/2008 on the housing sector. This, and the inordinate length of time taken to approve the Fife Development Plan, has delayed all substantial private house-builder activity in Cupar. Cupar has however been fortunate to have 18 new affordable homes right in the town centre – a part of the CARS/THI scheme for the County Buildings.
While the Tay Cities Deal’s main target in Fife is the St Andrews University ecological development at Guardbridge, some infrastructure in North East Fife may be funded, and this could include a contribution to the Cupar relief road. This would be particularly welcome because the Planning condition currently proposed would demand construction of that road only after the completion of the first 600 houses. This would have a serious impact on congestion and pollution, as much of the additional traffic generated would be fighting its way through the narrow town centre. Negotiations on infrastructure generally – schools, medical services, drainage and other services – have added to delays.
CDT and its partner organisations expect a major part of their efforts over the next three years, and beyond, to be raising funding for, and then delivering, small projects supported by HLF and others. Out of that experience, it will become clearer what the delivery of the Interpretive Plan, and other aspirations identified during the Charrette process, will require, including what structures will be best suited to the tasks. These tasks go beyond heritage alone, and will include social, cultural and environmental initiatives, with a strong element of education incorporated. Success in those will contribute to economic improvement.
You can follow progress via www.cupardevtrust.org.uk, Twitter @CuparCould, Instagram @CuparCould and Facebook.
BACK
Lesley Martin, strategic planner and doctoral researcher, reflects of the challenges and opportunities presented by public engagement and participation.

Lochrin Canal, Edinburgh: image Scottish Canals
Process trumps outcomes?
People may seek a connection but not necessarily active participation; processes are as important to communities as outcomes; and access does not equate to influence. I have been struck by how new studies are uncovering paradoxes and complexities that will continue to make effective participation a challenge. Nick Wright’s interesting case study of his work on community-led planning in Lockerbie is a useful reminder first, that many tools and techniques for community engagement already exist, and second, that there are many ways of becoming ‘involved’.
The public engagement paradox
One issue under more recent scrutiny is the degree to which inequality plays out in participation processes. This has been studied in depth by What Works Scotland in a 2017 evidence review, which analysed 70 studies of the link between community engagement and inequality – surprisingly rare in research studies. In covering dimensions familiar to practitioners: power; partnerships; representation; digital resources; funding; it also confirms ‘hard to shift’ barriers including unrealisable expectations and unrealistic burdens on the few – for example 7% of the Scottish population have volunteered 13 times or more in the previous year under study.
The study also highlights the ’public engagement paradox’, indicating that as participation has grown, so too has inequality. The risk therefore is that unequal societal power, embodied in the ‘rituals’ which are part and parcel of community engagement events, may be reproduced in participative processes.
Nick’s call for resources to support participative processes is echoed in the WWS report which particularly emphasises the need for ‘support to participate’ as a way to equalise opportunity. Jury members are reimbursed for travel expenses, so why should not citizens performing other forms of public service be recognised?
Challenge to linear participation models – embrace the ‘messiness’?
Engagement methods continue to favour ‘rational’ models – popular with strategists and embedded in public policy thinking, yet the essential ‘messiness’ and non-linearity of participative processes seems likely to be an increasing feature in the future. The toolkits we use may therefore need re-imagining. And the need for training is likely to increase – not just for communities, but for the people who organise and facilitate such processes.
In their work on the need for a ‘culture of kindness’ in public services, the Carnegie Trust explores not just the what, but the ‘how’ of service delivery, arguing that the ‘enabling State’ must rethink the modern model of ‘the public servant’ as someone comfortable about going beyond their role. This raises the question about the direction in which local government may find itself travelling, if the twin aims of efficiency and democracy are to be reconciled.
Co-operation needn’t mean consensus
Although Nick’s article questions whether community-led plans really need to be complicated, the drive to inclusion may indeed make participative processes even more complex and potentially confrontational. Moreover, the diagnosis of problems and suggested solutions will inevitably be interpreted differently by ever more participants. Consensus remains a worthwhile goal but learning to understand – while not necessarily agree with – other perspectives which may appear unjust, perverse or plain daft, is a difficult and time-consuming activity. Co-operation doesn’t have to imply consensus, therefore participative outputs may quite rightly express a range of views.
2018 – a year of experiment
As the planning profession enters an important year of change in the wake of new legislation, the experience of planners, who have been practicing participation longer than most, if not all, other professions, should be at the forefront of new thinking. At least there is the learning from the last half century to go on – and the experience of hundreds of excellent recent exemplars around the country. Nevertheless, the context, framing of the policy issues and the public discourse is unique for our times – and therefore so too must be the responses. 2018 is shaping up to be a fascinating year of experiment.
References
1. Nick Wright on LinkedIN ‘Real Community Planning in Lockerbie‘ posted 2 January 2018.
2. Lightbody, R. (2017) Hard to reach’ or ‘easy to ignore’? Promoting equality in community engagement, Edinburgh: What Works Scotland.
3. Brotchie, J. (2017) What do Citizens Want? How professional help and support fits into day to day lives, Edinburgh: The Carnegie Trust.
Lesley Martin MRTPI MCMI FRSA
Consultant and Doctoral Researcher
@lesleymartin216
email: lesley@lesleymartinconsulting.com
www: lesleymartinconsulting.com
Blog originally posted on LinkedIn on 4th January 2018.
BACK
BEFS Director, Euan Leitch, reflects on linkages between recent built environment events and academic analysis, in light of the forthcoming changes in the funding landscape.
The two-day Community Heritage Conference in Glasgow in early November was a real celebration of the breadth of activity taking place across Scotland, with some inspirational projects from further afield showcased. Catherine Gillies’ rallying talk on Saturday morning was a call for the creation of a Community Heritage Network to establish just quite how extensive the activity is and then to offer mutual support.
I then sat in on a fascinating session on Communities and Asset Transfers, chaired by Linda Gillespie of COSS where we heard details from the experiences of the Gairloch Heritage Museum, Govanhill Baths and Braemar Castle. Each reflected their varying locations and communities and are all successful projects – Govanhill Baths subsequently having gone on to raise £267,000 through community shares. All talked of the challenges of fundraising and of volunteer burn out. In the panel discussion Fatima Uygun made some interesting comments on the danger of communities ultimately delivering services that should be delivered by the state.
Community empowerment and asset transfer are not just buzzwords, they are legislative acts of the Scottish Parliament intended to enable communities to have more control of the places in which they live and the services delivered there. The three examples mentioned illustrate different forms this can take and the Conference only showcases the heritage portion of activity and the extent of volunteering in this area alone is large.
Two days before the Community Heritage Conference the International Journal of Heritage Studies published a paper titled Endangerment-driven heritage volunteering: democratisation or ‘Changeless Change’ by Harald Friedman of the University of York that makes thought provoking reading. Friedman posits that the attempt to democratise heritage through increased public participation may actually reinforce existing power structures (through neoliberal approaches) and result in “exploiting volunteers, devaluing professionals and marginalising traditionally underrepresented demographics”. He writes from a position that not everything can, or should, be saved and is critical of some of the claims made about the instrumental role of heritage as championed by some heritage bodies. Is greater public participation in heritage unwittingly enabling the austerity agenda? Or is community empowerment the necessary response to gaps arising to due to public sector cuts?
It was a delight to see one community lead project, Hastings Pier, win the RIBA Stirling Prize in October. It is a £14million pound project that resurrected the burnt-out pier with fundraising under community ownership achieved through community shares that raised £258,000. It’s then sad news that the Hastings Pier Charity has already gone into administration as funders rejected its 3 year business plan. Understandably, funders are seeking evidence that a project is financially sustainable but how easy is sustainability in a period of reduced public spending and economic instability?
The Heritage Lottery Fund was one of the main funders of Hastings Pier but even its generous grants are now challenged as a result of a drop in people buying lottery tickets. The recent Tailored Review has published its recommendations and the HLF has already responded with some significant interim changes to its grant making programme for 2019. There will be no major grants (over £5m) and there will be further open consultation on the best use of Heritage Lottery Funds: are the big projects the best use of funds, or is it a smaller but wider spread that benefits communities most?
Entrepreneurship and pragmatism are necessary in securing the assets we want future generations to benefit. However, the question remains whether or not community ownership is going to result in sustainable uses in the long term. This may require prioritisation – of assets? Of communities? – But just who is willing and able to rise to the challenge of prioritisation?
BACK
Lauren Pennycook, Policy and Development Officer, Carnegie UK Trust, reflects on their latest report published this week and the challenges facing Scotland’s towns.
The places where we live are critical to our wellbeing. The physical and social structures of our cities, towns, villages, and islands provide us with economic and social opportunities; formal support systems in local public services; and informal support systems in the relationships with our friends, families, and neighbours. From small rural settlements to large urban cities, in upland, lowland, and coastal communities, where we call home provides us with a unique sense of place, identity, and shared history which shapes the local narrative about where we live.
And a town is where millions of us across the UK and Ireland call home. What our towns are ‘known for’ – an industry, a prominent historical figure, or renowned architecture – forms part of the local, positive story about where we live. But in direct contrast to this, in national policy the narrative is largely negative and one of decline. Our towns are defined in relation to the nearest city – as ‘commuter’, ‘satellite’ or ‘dormitory’ – or by their past – as ‘former-coal’ or ‘post-industrial’ – in need of regeneration, resilience or future-proofing.
According to Malcolm Fraser, Chair of the National Review of Town Centres External Advisory Group, here in Scotland ‘[t]he argument is generally accepted, that bustling cities are a nation’s economic powerhouses, where social and cultural interaction drives innovation and wealth-creation. Scotland would benefit from more big-city-bustle. But big powerhouses also need a network of vigorous, smaller centres around them, and some of our town centres have lost that drive.’
Has such a framing of towns at the national level influenced the priorities, funding, and focus of our governments in developing place-based policies? The Carnegie UK Trust’s provides an overview of the main policies and initiatives designed to improve economic, social, environmental, and democratic outcomes in places across the jurisdictions. At the regional level, the impact of City Deals and related cities policy is rendering the regions surrounding powerhouse cities, and their composite towns, as the secondary focus for investment. As the initial City Deal agreements do not provide full details on timescales and the location of all investments, as seen in the Edinburgh and South East Scotland City Region Deal, it may take longer for some areas to reap the benefit, and as such there have been mixed reactions to the plans from local government and the business sector.
Equally dominant in the place-based approach taken by governments across the jurisdictions is investment in rural areas, which includes surrounding towns on the basis that they are in fact vital, if only for the economic development of rural areas. Integrating towns into rural policy assumes that supporting rural areas with a range of goods and services is the primary function of nearby towns, but there is very little data available to support this expectation.
The operating assumption appears to be that investment in nearby cities and rural hinterlands will inevitably lead to improved outcomes for their surrounding towns, despite towns being fundamentally different socio-economic geographies which require their own dedicated policy solutions to improve their performance.
While locally, policies are operating at a sub-town level. In Scotland, the focus is on town centre regeneration and community-led regeneration – focusing on physical parts of a town or individual communities with it – to the detriment of the wider town in which they sit. But the issues experienced by Scotland’s towns go far beyond the boundaries of their town centres or one community. As a result, this approach is piecemeal – austerity meaning that it never translates into anything more than the sum of its parts to consider the town in its totality.
This dual focus – on the external city or surrounding rural hinterland and internal sub-town community or part of a town – means that towns are a neglected area of public policy. They are rarely taken as the starting point for formal policymaking, or have the policy levers available to them to influence their fortunes.
So what can be done to address this policy gap? The rhetoric of devolution needs to be matched with the reality of more decision-making powers for towns; more data about towns and evidence about what works; and more opportunities for towns to work together. From international initiatives such as the World Towns Framework, to the UK cross-border such as the Borderlands Initiative, to the more immediately local such as the South of Scotland Alliance, there are opportunities for towns to share skills, knowledge and resources. These must be built upon to share successes, and challenges, to improving our places.
Of all the jurisdictions of the UK and Ireland, Scotland is well placed to take steps towards addressing this policy and advocacy gap. Scotland’s Towns Partnership is unique across the jurisdictions as a dedicated resource for information, advice, and sharing of expertise regarding the development of towns in Scotland. Given that towns are a system of component parts and affected by a large number of policy areas – housing; transport; economic development; culture; heritage; land ownership; and regional development, more organisations with a range of remits should join in the debate about how to improve Scotland’s towns. Because only through greater collaboration will towns and their practitioners have the strength in numbers to hold their own in the national policy arena with the well-resourced organisations advocating for the interests of cities and rural areas. Only through greater collaboration will it be time for towns.
Follow the Carnegie UK Trust on Twitter: @CarnegieUKTrust
and
BACK
Joanna Hambly, The SCAPE Trust, tells us about Scotland’s Coastal Heritage At Risk Project and the role of volunteers in surveying Scotland’s coastal archaeological heritage.
Between 2012 and 2016, the SCAPE Trust recruited, trained and supported volunteers to carry out a national survey of coastal archaeological heritage threatened by erosion. The survey formed part of the wider Scotland’s Coastal Heritage at Risk Project (SCHARP), funded and supported by the Heritage Lottery Fund, Historic Environment Scotland, the University of St Andrews and Local Authorities across Scotland. The project has been transformative to SCAPE as an organisation; to how we share and manage information about Scotland’s coastal heritage; and to our capacity to monitor, update and investigate eroding coastal heritage sites. The results provide up-to-date information within the 35% of the coastline subject to the surveys, which will help inform local and national priorities for action at the most vulnerable and important coastal heritage sites.
SCHARP builds upon data collected through an analysis of Coastal Zone Assessment Surveys (CZAS) commissioned by Historic Environment Scotland between 1996 and 2010. SCHARP was developed to address the need to review and update site condition data of important coastal heritage sites threatened by coastal processes in order to better understand what currently was most at risk and where. Our aim was to put volunteers at the heart of this process by recruiting, training and supporting volunteers in coastal communities to carry out site visits and surveys in their local areas. The primary focus was to identify the highest priority sites currently at risk in order to provide a firm evidence base for practical action.
The outstanding contribution of over 1000 volunteers in the project as a whole, 500 of whom took part in the surveys, enabled us to more than meet the project goals. Volunteers submitted 1041 updated surveys of CZAS sites and visited 88% of the 322 highest priority sites identified in the previous desk-based analysis of CZAS data. This observational data was moderated by SCAPE officers and used to review the status of every site submitted.
“We’ve come to recognise things and there is definitely this sixth sense you develop about spotting things in the landscape – suddenly you get this feeling at the back of your neck when you’re looking at something that shouldn’t be there. We’re becoming better at the recording is what I’m saying.” feedback from volunteer in the Western Isles.
As a result of the review 145 sites were assigned a highest priority score. Two thirds of these retained their priority status from the original CZAS analysis and one third came from new sites or sites that had not been identified previously as a priority. The proportion of highest priority sites in each region remained similar when compared to the original CZAS analysis. The coastlines of the Northern and Western Isles are most vulnerable to erosion and contain two thirds of all high priority sites.
Much of the reduction in the absolute number of highest priority sites can be explained by the SCHARP survey and analysis methodology, which assessed the relative condition and vulnerability of each site on a national scale, introducing parity when considering priority across the whole of Scotland. A second factor may be attributed to a general, possibly short-term, trend of stabilisation of sand dune and machair coastlines compared to conditions when some of the original CZAS surveys were completed. Changes in land management, the timing of the surveys and meteorological trends may account for this. This demonstrates the potential of regular monitoring of eroding coastal heritage sites to describe wider trends of coastal change.
We have learned a great deal from SCHARP and have built relationships with our network of volunteers that will stand us, and Scotland’s capacity to continue monitoring coastal heritage, in good stead for the future.
“Excellent team and a really good idea to get community involvement where amateurs can feel that they can make a real contribution” feedback following training event in North Uist.
New knowledge has been created and shared. The surveys have produced empirical information for use in the management of threatened coastal heritage and have highlighted a valuable resource with significant research and learning potential.
SCHARP has also demonstrated that large-scale volunteer input is compatible with high quality information and research outcomes. It provides a model of volunteer involvement in the monitoring of heritage assets which could be effectively applied to any national heritage resource.
“I suggest that our professional organisations can and should develop just a few long-term collaborative strategies for integrating archaeological knowledge of human history. Two examples of tactics show how archaeology and climate change concerns intersect at community and global levels. The first is SCAPE where archaeologists have reached beyond traditional heritage management to empower local communities to document, excavate and conserve coastal archaeological sites …..The key here is archaeological empowerment of local communities as not only first responders but also true knowledge producers.” Diane Gifford-Gonzalez, Opening address of the World Archaeology Congress, Kyoto, October 2016.
- Follow SCHARP on Facebook and Twitter @CoastArch.
- Scotland’s Coastal Heritage at Risk: Final Evaluation Report
- A Review of Heritage at Risk from Coastal Processes in Scotland
BACK









