BEFS Director, Euan Leitch, reflects on responses to the Planning (Scotland) Bill since it was passed.

It has been a week since the Planning (Scotland) Bill was passed, after 3½ years of intensive activity across professional organisations, third sector groups and  communities. When the “root and branch” review of the planning system was announced for the Scottish Government’s programme in 2015 it had the following aims:

  • Ensure that planning realises its full potential, unlocking land and sites, supporting more quality housing across all tenures and delivering the infrastructure required to support development.
  • Streamline, simplify and improve current systems and remove unnecessary blockages in the decision-making process.
  • Ensure that communities are more engaged in the process.
  • Continue to meet our statutory and international obligations in protecting and enhancing Scotland’s nature and environment.

Has the Bill achieved those aims? On the evidence of the Bill alone, it seems doubtful and most commentators await secondary legislation.

There have been very few press releases to date (or at least published) and most positive comments are in response to individual aspects of the Bill. RTPI Scotland welcome the introduction of Chief Planning Officers and retention of regional spatial strategies but question the availability of funding new aspects – Local Place Plans and Mediation?  Calum Macleod of Community Land Scotland welcomes parts of the Bill that address rural repopulation. The BBC provided a summary of the Bill, as did CommonSpace and Lesley Riddoch covered aspects in a podcast, but complained that no national newspaper was interested enough in planning to publish a piece on it. Cliff Hague has offered perhaps the most detailed analysis and comment. Neil Collar of Brodies’ summation concludes that while not a reforming piece of legislation, “useful conversations have been started”.

Anderson Strathearn held a breakfast seminar yesterday primarily attended by the development industry with presentations from Lichfields, Gladman Land and Playfair Scotland. The consensus was relief at not totally losing regional spatial strategies, fears about losing influence in the gatecheck process for local development plans and further relief that land value capture had not been fully introduced. There was no strong conviction that it would result in the delivery of more housing or that local place plans or the introduction of mediation would satisfy community needs. While this sounds downbeat, it was more of a ‘phew’ that no new obstacles had been introduced, and the defeat of third party right of appeal, described as a “victory” for industry, with that being attributed to the successful lobbying of the Scottish Property Federation. One industry representative was more positive, citing the housing target being in the National Planning Framework as of benefit, but followed that by encouraging developers to “pretend to trust” planning authorities when engaging with them.

It is perhaps telling that there is little comment on the Bill as a whole, just praise for individual aspects reflecting a particular interest or disappointment that certain amendments were voted down. What is notably absent is any community group recognising greatly improved engagement as a result.

Perhaps the blueprint for a streamlined and more engaging process will be revealed in secondary legislation, although as observed by Alastair Mckie yesterday, they may well be mutually exclusive goals. Secondary legislation was the answer to many questions as the Bill proceeded though committees at Stage 2 – will it be jam tomorrow?


Postscript: commentary has subsequently been published by Planning Democracy, Scottish Green Infrastructure Forum and Heads of Planning Scotland. 09 July 2019

BACK

RTPI President Ian Tant shares his impressions of his recent visit to Scotland.

Originally publish on the RTPI website on 25 June 2019

On a sunny midsummer morning, there are few more dramatic sights than that of approaching Stirling with the Castle sparkling above and the Highlands gleaming in the background.  The view from Dumyat Path in the Ochil Hills is equally stirring, stretching across the city from the Highlands in the west to the Forth and Grangemouth in the east.

Stirling Enhanced Landscape Mitigation Project

It’s into this spectacular landscape that Scottish Power Energy Networks had the task of inserting a major power line on 604 high towers.  How to mitigate its impact on the landscape? The identified solution was a progressive programme of engagement with the nine local communities.

Ideas were drawn up with each of the community groups, leading to tree and woodland planting in some areas and improved access in others, such as new paths and cycleways and footpath improvements.  Connecting places and improving accessibility were seen as a key priority in all the communities.

At Dumyat Path, the project has involved a new car park, rebuilding several kilometres of dry stone wall, and footpath enhancements on the hillside. It’s little wonder then that the Stirling Enhanced Landscape Mitigation Project won this year’s RTPI award for Excellence in Planning for the Natural Environment.

Dargavel Village – excellence in large housing delivery

Equally impressive is Dargavel Village, winner of the Large Housing category at the Awards.  Occupying 964 hectares of a former Royal Ordnance Factory on the edge of Bishopton, the village is developed according to a masterplan and design guides produced through partnership working between the owners, BAe Systems, Renfrewshire Council and the local community.  The result is a truly high quality development that makes a major contribution to meeting housing needs of the area and regenerating a major derelict site.

But it has also taken perseverance in the face of challenging economic circumstances and serious contamination issues for the scheme to be delivered.

Over 1,000 of the 4,000 homes have been built and a new village centre is nearing completion close to Bishopton railway station, one of the key links between the existing and new villages.

Innovation is playing its part too.  Taylor Wimpey have chosen Dargavel for the company’s Project 2020 scheme – new architect-designed homes meeting a brief set by customer survey and incorporating modern methods of construction, flexible interior layouts and low-carbon energy systems that look ahead to the zero net carbon target.

My visit to the Scottish Parliament coincided with the chance to witness the passing of the new Planning Bill, a major reform of the Scottish Planning System.

Containing many positive provisions including the statutory requirement for Chief Planning Officers, the Bill has proven controversial with the passion behind the debates highlighting the importance of planning to the politicians and communities of Scotland.

Excellence in planning for health and well being

Communities lie at the heart of the Cuningar Loop Woodland Park, winner of the RTPI Planning Excellence Award for Health and Wellbeing.  Here, the Clyde Gateway Urban Regeneration Company has worked closely with South Lanarkshire District and Glasgow City Councils, the Forestry Commission and local communities to deliver a country park right alongside the East End of Glasgow.

The park stands on what was wasteland – literally, in that the ground is filled with rubble (and worse) overspilling from the city.  Masonry blocks come to the surface and are reused as sculptural features.  A new footbridge over the Clyde links the former Commonwealth Games athletes village, now converted to homes for the local community, to the footpaths, riverside boardwalks and open spaces of the park.

Whilst holding firm to a vision of a place that could improve health and wellbeing, Clyde Gateway planners have shown that adaptivity is an important part of the planners’ toolkit.  The park continues to develop, with new features planned and exploration for ground-source heat underway in a corner of the site.

Dundee Waterfront

Finally, all credit for the award-winning Dundee Waterfront development lies firmly with the planners and councillors of the City Council, who have worked hard to instil belief and confidence in the reshaping of this former industrial area.  The use of digital technology has been at the heart of public engagement over the masterplan and proposals.

The exciting new building of the V&A Dundee provides an inspiring centrepiece to new public realm and there is huge optimism that new hotels and offices are on their way to complete this important regeneration project.

Planning lies front and centre in each of the impressive RTPI award-winning schemes, demonstrating yet again the vision, leadership, community engagement, determination and adaptability of our important profession.

Ian Tant, President of the RTPI.

 

BACK

BEFS Vice-Chair, Professor Ian Baxter (Heriot-Watt University), introduces his new Heritage Career Guide in association with BEFS and The Heritage Alliance.

It is the time of the year when undergraduates are coming to the end of their courses and looking toward graduation and the big blue yonder beyond, and postgraduates are theoretically scurrying about collecting data and writing furiously for completion of their Masters dissertations over the summer. Regardless, both groups of students are wondering what the future will hold, and for those who have chosen to follow the noble path of heritage management – they are most likely wondering where on earth they are going to find a job to pay the bills.

The heritage sector might seem a small world, but it has a myriad of possibilities, given the uses to which heritage is put these days. In terms of careers and job hunting, this can be somewhat bewildering, with the ‘obvious’ heritage jobs of working in a museum or at a historic site both hard to spot and in relatively small supply in comparison to the number of heritage-related graduates the education system seems to be churning out.

Once upon a time, newspapers would be the obvious place to look for jobs, but with advertising budgets almost non-existent, signposting to the nooks and crannies of the sector where jobs may be found is all the more important. The Heritage Careers Guide has therefore been overdue: conscious that I am an academic in the sector helping to produce those heritage graduates, and mindful as a BEFS and Heritage Alliance trustee that the organisations could be doing more to link students, universities and heritage bodies – I finally spent a bit of time editing lists and tidying up bookmarks which have signposted students to jobs over the years, and compiled a focused guide on where to start the search.

Since it was quietly launched earlier in the month, the guide has been downloaded almost 500 times, which suggests that it is already proving to be a useful resource. I will develop it over time – and welcome feedback and suggestions for the next edition at @ibheritage / i.baxter@hw.ac.uk. Please feel free to re-use the resource, link to it, embed it in your website – and good luck in any job hunting!

Next on my agenda is a resource guide for the best heritage newsletters and bulletins to sign up for… (with the BEFS Bulletin and Heritage Update at the top of the list of course!).

Professor Ian Baxter

 

 

BACK

BEFS Policy Lead, Ailsa Macfarlane, explores the implications of climate change goals for policy in the built environment.

The delivery of Rescue & Reuse to my desk sped-up a train of thought. It arrived the same week the Committee on Climate Change released their most recent report. This document has been much lauded by Governments, committees, climate-change organisations and industry. I’m not here to disagree with the premise – but there is a caveat, one included by the Committee on Climate Change themselves:

[net-zero 2050] is only possible if clear, stable and well-designed policies to reduce emissions further are introduced across the economy without delay. Current policy is insufficient for even the existing targets.

The report is clear, there is not one-solution to achieving the aims set-out. The approaches will need to be integrated across all aspects of our economy and society. This has been echoed and endorsed by the Scottish Government’s recent statement: [we] will be placing climate change at the heart of everything we do. … it will be at the core of our next Programme for Government and Spending Review.

Recently BEFS, and the Tenement Maintenance Working Group (TMWG) have responded to a number of consultations which connect our built environment and the environmental crisis. The Infrastructure Commission for Scotland has rightly declared housing as infrastructure – a step which is hopefully useful from a resourcing, as well as climate, perspective. And, in responding to Housing Beyond 2021, TMWG noted: It is regularly forecast that 80% of existing homes will still be in use in 2050 and it is therefore imperative that these be maintained in good condition to meet both fuel poverty and carbon emission targets.

In a response to Scottish Climate Change Adaptation Programme, BEFS championed the importance of our historic built environment as resilient, but needing, as all buildings do, appropriate maintenance; this, and adaptation, retro-fitting and reuse (many categories of which are covered in inspiring case studies within Rescue & Reuse) will enable the historic environment to play its essential role as an adaptable resource, and a source of embodied energy, capable of mitigating against negative impact on our climate. These benefits can only be fully realised should the appropriate skills, resources, and polices, be in place.

It is obviously not just our existing built environment which will have a role to play, but that which we choose to build. The Scottish Government global climate emergency statement is clear that the current Planning (Scotland) Bill will not be reworked in light of recent reports, but: the next National Planning Framework and review of the Scottish Planning Policy will include considerable focus on how the planning system can support our climate change goals.

So many of the issues connecting the built environment to climate-crisis are about enabling and promoting genuine sustainability. There are policy levers which could help: VAT parity, EPC assessment which is accurate to building type, return to use of empty-homes, community empowerment, HES Policy and Managing Change guidance, and planning legislation itself.

I started by asking if it’s all about behaviour change, and whilst technologies (new and adaptive) will have a significant part to play, the more important question is, ‘whose behaviour needs to change?’. If we need radical change, then the policies set by elected leadership need to reflect this. Much like reducing smoking and cigarette purchases, or increasing safety in cars with seat-belts – the behaviour change necessary was ‘pushed’ via legislation. The difficult choices need to be made – at legislative as well as personal levels. Our extant built-environment is most-often found in places which are already connected – part of a greater intersection of policies, people and places. These places can of course be made more efficient – both in relation to how the buildings operate, but also how we live our lives: consuming fewer resources, producing less CO2 emissions.

Carlo Scarpa wrote, ‘Our duty is to give buildings a new lease of life so that they may be able to live today and tomorrow’. Perhaps our collective duty now is to give buildings a new lease of life so that we may be able to live today and tomorrow.

BACK

Former BEFS Chair, Graeme Purves, has published a think piece on Strategic Development in Scotland with the UK2070 Commission.

The UK2070 Commission led by Lord Kerslake is currently working on a framework to address spatial inequalities across the United Kingdom. Former BEFS Chair, Graeme Purves, is a member of the Commission and has written a think piece reflecting on his time as Assistant Chief Planner with the Scottish Government, where he led the teams which prepared Scotland’s First and Second National Planning Frameworks.

Graeme provides a review of strategic development in Scotland since the 1940s, with a particular focus on Scotland’s National Planning Framework and its role in the designation of national developments to facilitate the delivery of infrastructure projects of national importance. He highlights relevant issues emerging from the current debate over Scotland’s Planning Bill and outlines recent developments in Scotland’s distinctive land reform agenda. He identifies strengthening regional agency, improving connectivity and the quality of place, and land reform and resettlement as key elements of the agenda for Scotland’s strategic development in the medium to long term.

Read the full think piece here: Strategic Development in Scotland

BACK

Jeff Sanders, Dig It! Project Manager with the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, tells us about the process of bringing Archaeology and Minecraft together, following the recent inspiring Edinburgh Science Festival event.

If you ask a roomful of people if anyone wanted to be an archaeologist when they grew up, chances are you’ll see a good few raised hands. And why wouldn’t you? It’s all about discovering and telling stories, meeting like-minded people and finding new things.

At Dig It!, we’re striving for a Scotland where everyone enjoys – and can engage with – archaeology. However, many people who would like to get involved think that archaeology is not “for them”: a challenge that likely resonates with the wider heritage sector.

We’ve found that the best way of getting people involved is to meet them halfway – find a hook within their own interests. One of our most successful hooks has been Minecraft, the ubiquitous video game which could be described as “digital LEGO”.

We recently launched the Crafting the Past website with nine maps packed with stories, and games that can be downloaded  for free (as long as Minecraft is already on the user’s device).Each Crafting the Past map features a real Scottish site which has been meticulously recreated, including a restored (and burned down) mansion, an entire abandoned island, a buried Pictish hillfort and reimagined museums. We’ve showcased them on high streets, at international gaming festivals, and at the very sites that we’ve reconstructed. All in all, it’s a fun game and it’s a nice excuse to have it on my work computer.

If Minecraft doesn’t sound right for you, there are lots of other games-based and non-games-based way to get people involved, and I wanted to share three lessons we’ve learned along the way that might be of broader interest:

  1. WORK WITH A NEW (NON-HERITAGE) PARTNER: We knew nothing about Minecraft or games-based learning approaches until we met Immersive Minds, who have employees in the centre of the Venn diagram of understanding the technology, the learning potential, and how to communicate it. Working with a partner outside of the heritage sector also brought unexpended benefits. For example, showcasing Crafting the Past at a games festival that attracts more than 70,000 people wasn’t out of the ordinary for them. The tricky part was getting used to a different sector and way of working – that required building a partnership-based approach rather than a straightforward client-provider relationship.
  2. CONCISE STORYTELLING: Our builds feature topographically accurate landscapes, painstakingly decorated buildings, and accurate archaeological sites. But this wasn’t enough for us. We needed these downloadable maps to be story-driven in order to be engaging, which gives us a conduit for years of archaeological data gathered from excavations, archives, museums and labs. While working with Immersive Minds, I realised that there I was in danger of focusing too closely on the data; fetishizing the “stuff” as opposed to telling the story.  If we want to make an impactful and lasting connection with a new audience, we need to be canny and concise in our storytelling – not all-encompassing, and not overly hung-up on specific details.
  3. POWER TO THE PEOPLE: I quickly learned that you can’t teach a young person much about Minecraft, but you can use Minecraft to spark their interest in archaeology. Minecraft has the advantage of being “off the shelf”, with a dedicated community of over 90 million users playing each month. I’ve enjoyed seeing people explore Scotland’s past on their own terms through an environment that they can happily navigate. Reaching out and putting archaeology outside of our own comfort zone has been an important lesson (with the added benefit of not having to reinvent the wheel).

There are lots of ways to engage people. And games are just one conduit. In recent years, archaeologists have teamed up with artists, musicians, brewers and weavers to name but a few. However you decide to “meet people halfway” it’s the enthusiasm and stories that need to shine through. Happy gaming!

————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————————-

Thanks to Edinburgh International Science Festival and Baillie Gifford for supporting the launch of Crafting the Past and Historic Environment Scotland for supporting the Dig It! project

For further online reading, The Interactive Past has some great international examples, including both bespoke games and pre-existing examples which have been repurposed.

Jeff Sanders, Dig It! Project Manager with the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland.

BACK

BEFS Director looks at the implications of two of the recommendations arising from a Parliamentary Committee report on the Glasgow School of Art fire.

The Scottish Parliament’s Culture, Tourism, Europe and External Affairs Committee published a report on the Glasgow School of Art Mackintosh Building a fortnight ago. While the Committee has been investigating fire risk management and governance issues at the GSA they have also made recommendations on the remit of Historic Environment Scotland. While a lot of people have opinions on the fire at the GSA it is the latter that is of interest as it could have strategic implications for Scotland’s cultural heritage.

The Committee gathered evidence from interested parties in written form and through four sessions in the Parliament, the last of which included contributions from Historic Environment Scotland. The session reveals that some MSPs have the, not uncommon, misperception that HES is the custodian of all of Scotland’s listed buildings, policing everything in relation to them. One query was whether or not HES assess the suitability of owners of category A listed buildings. The HES representatives are clear on their role as guardian of the Properties in Care but explain that their role in the care and management of the other 46,000+ listed buildings is advisory and that they do not assess owner suitability.  The point that HES operate in advisory capacity is made repeatedly. The record of the session makes interesting reading.

The Committee report makes the following two recommendations specific to Historic Environment Scotland:

The Committee is concerned that the listing system employed by HES covers a very large number of properties and contains no formal mechanism for recognising that there is a smaller sub-set of Category A Listed properties that are of significant cultural and historic importance to Scotland. The Committee recommends that HES and the Scottish Government consider a more tailored form of categorisation that would provide specific protection to buildings of unique cultural and historic significance.

The Committee notes the remit of Historic Environment Scotland is to have a leadership role in relation to the conservation and preservation of historic buildings. Despite this, the Committee considers that Historic Environment Scotland adopted an arms-length approach to the Mackintosh building with regards to safeguarding it from fire. Accordingly, the Committee recommends that the Scottish Government reviews the remit of Historic Environment Scotland and considers giving it extended statutory powers to intervene in cases where there is a risk to an asset of national significance.

Only 7% of listed buildings are category A, around 3200, and the Committee are proposing that another subset of unique cultural and historically significant buildings is identified, let’s call it a category A*. They are also recommending that HES has greater interventionary powers for assets of national significance that are at risk.

While it could be argued that all listed buildings are of national significance and therefore all of the 1890 listed buildings on the buildings at risk register require HES intervention, 347 of which are category A, it may be safe to assume that the Committee is recommending greater statutory powers for the category A* listed buildings at risk. What would qualify as A* at risk? Take your pick from these asylum’s, churches, doocots, winter gardens, piers, castles, mud cottages, mortuaries and mills.

During recent discussions on the review of the criteria for listing, abolishing categories was mooted by some, what would the response be to further categorisation? BEFS own recent investigations on the theme of prioritisation reveals how challenging that is and identifying the crème de la crème of Scotland’s built heritage would likely be a thorny process.

The Committee will not be alone in wishing HES had greater powers to intervene. Arguably, such powers already exist with local authorities but, needless to say, they do not have the resources to use them. If the power were transferred to HES would it be resourced to apply them? The Scottish Government’s funding of HES continues to diminish annually, albeit healthily augmented in recent years by high income generation through ticket sales at Edinburgh Castle and Castle Urquhart. But if the Committee’s recommendations were to be accepted by the Scottish Government then the expanded statutory remit would require additional resource for it to have a meaningful impact. It will be interesting to see how the Cabinet Secretary for Culture, Tourism and External Affairs responds.

Then again, Glasgow School of Art was not on an at risk register so even if these recommendations had been in place, it is unlikely they would have prevented the fire of June 2018. The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service has yet to publish its report on the cause of the fire, a vital component that the Tourism, Europe and External Affairs Committee should maybe have waited for.

The full report is available here.

BACK

BEFS Policy & Advocacy Officer, Ailsa Macfarlane reflects on the ‘Scotland at a Crossroads, Heritage Past and Futures’ Symposium

Symposium – Intercultural Research Centre, Heriot Watt – 13 March 2019

Scotland, the United Kingdom and Europe find themselves at a cross-roads. Perhaps it wouldn’t be presumptuous to say that a cross-roads is almost too straightforward for the juncture we are now at, politically and perhaps even emotionally. At the Heriot Watt event (detailed above) academics and researchers explored the personal and the political in relation to heritage. Many aspects were covered and I highly recommend that those interested explore the link above where presentations from the day will be posted in due course.

Dr Gina Netto explored what heritage is – how it is defined, how it is expressed and experienced. And how migration is represented, albeit selectively, within heritage expression. Scotland’s heritage is often, too often, represented by our built environment.
This raised questions of language – does our reliance on ‘heritage’ and the historic environment (as defined via our national policies) rather than ‘cultural heritage’, by necessity become exclusionary? Are we pushing the people out of our stories?

The scene set, we heard two more personal perspective on belonging, (longing to be, Dr Lina Fadel) and the choice, or imposition of belonging. Dr Katerina Strani brought us into the world of multicultural citizenship and the importance of interculturalism as helping to form cohesive civil societies through the notion of multiple identities. The salad bowl, rather than the melting pot.
Scotland was seen as a positive example – New Scots are being welcomed, multilingualism is championed (Gaelic, BSL), migrants are normalised into the dominant publics. And to an extent this is amplified by Brexit – Scotland is defining itself in relation to another, less inclusive seeming other. However, Dr Emma Hill highlighted the discourse of the ‘New Scot’ as often unrelated to length of settlement/time in a place – and how this manifested in relation to Glasgow’s decades old Somali community.

Our keynote came from Dr Tuuli Lähdesmäki – Europe at a Crossroads. Cultural Heritage in the Creation of a European Narrative.
Culture as a tool of European creation and inclusion, or exclusion. Propaganda of the past, but also for the future. A single European-ness being central to a comprehensible European ideal. A shared ‘European identify’ which helps to bring cohesion – but excludes ideas of both nationality and aspects of the past which don’t contribute positively to the ideals for the future. The new European Heritage Label highlighting shared, yet diverse, heritages; increasing the politicisation of heritage – providing (sometimes spurious) parallels between the past and a shared political future. Heritage is a tool with diverse purposes – this is politics of scale; the sub-national example becoming the supra-national ideal.

The second session expanded on challenges, and echoed some of the questions raised around the Prioritisation work on which BEFS has been leading. Dr Jennie Morgan spoke of the profusion predicament and needing breadth for our future heritages. If 90% of museums’ collections are in stores – what are we seeing and ‘saving’ as representative of our pasts? New ways of thinking, unsettling the taken-for-granted assumptions and embracing a social inclusion agenda can give us some inroads into our future cultural heritage.

Catherine McCullagh’s ongoing research highlighted the perils of heritage professionals who may find themselves as gate-keepers of sentimental ideas; ideas which may not chime with communities’ own ideas of heritage, living or otherwise.

New approaches to living heritage are not without challenges: intangible cultural heritage (ICH) unchallenged, unexamined – with the potential to offend, commercialised (by accident or design). This ‘dark’ side was explored by Prof Alison McCleery – asking us to question ownership, notions of authenticity and conformity. Our behaviours and culture can adapt and change, but we need the confidence to question what is presented. Prof McCleery was plain that we, and UNSECO, cannot shy away from these difficult conversations.

In our final session music as heritage was explored by David Francis from TRACS – not just music as part of cultural expression but with the attendant ‘heritigisation’ – coming from assimilation, commoditisation and co-option of local singers to be recorded and be heard more widely. By promoting the recordings, what the singers represented became more static; the process of passing on the songs, as a living expression of the craft, was frozen becoming part of the ‘heritigisation’ of the cultural expression. How the parity of esteem for the traditional forms of cultural expression is maintained and expressed in the Culture Strategy will be interesting to see.

Marc Romano brought the ‘Outlander effect’ to the fore – the huge increase which some sites have experienced through new visitors. (An effect the heritage sector is clear comes with challenges and responsibilities.) Outlander-esque representations view Scottish ‘heritage’ through a very specific lens. A lens which elevates aspects of the past, perhaps beyond the reach of current cultural heritage grasping at parity.

Our final speaker, Alastair Mackie, discussed the notion of identity itself, only becoming an issue when it’s in crisis/uncertainty. The uncertainty in question remains Brexit.

The notions of the current liminality of Brexit and the personal and national impacts were discussed by a panel to close the day. Practical and personal concerns merged: visas, skills, information, disruption, racist slights, Imperialist attitudes and the disconnect between people and place.

Stewardship of land, of place, of how we prevent further climate breakdown all came to the fore. Is climate the crossroads we find ourselves at – is Brexit a mere bump in the road comparatively?

I found myself reflecting that so much of cultural heritage is how we steward our knowledge, what we choose to take forward, to leave as legacy, and to promote. I continue to assume that culture in its widest sense can be of benefit to societies, crossing barriers of demography – but perhaps the choices we make around what to foreground need more careful stewardship for the future.

 

BACK

BEFS Policy & Advocacy Officer, Ailsa Macfarlane asks, is it time to rethink our definition of community and consider how it is applied?

Is the concept of community, like the concept of the ‘housewife’ – somewhat dated, incongruous and failing to communicate the diversity of experience and circumstance? A label applied rather than a label chosen.

The following tweet helped to tease out some of the concerns I find with the current use of ‘community’ as a descriptor:

“How to make communities walkable – and better places to live […]”

It isn’t communities that become more walkable. It is places, areas – a mappable surface of land. Communities are truly formed – by and of – people; the place could be seen as subservient to those located there.

Community is too often used as a short-hand description for an area, with the people implied – but not necessarily central to the issue being discussed. In relation to the text of the tweet above – people will have to do the walking; this may involve difference choices and opportunities – it may involve understanding of behavior, it may require behavior-change; and those things involve individuals.

From a heritage perspective are we torn between place-based issues and communities which may be formed, defined and exist, out-with a locale? Simultaneously attempting to answer the issues of place and the rights and concerns of those involved.

We hear about Community values, community importance, community significance – but what do we really mean by community? I’m suspicious that what was once organic and holistic, (perhaps previously also based on assumption) is now fractured and manufactured. Something which is not necessarily innate.

Whilst it could be argued the formation of communities was always circumstantial – our circumstances seem now to have many more variables: from less homogenous groupings of relations, to further travel for service provision and/or employment, to more single-person dwellings.

If we asked people who their community are –would those around their locale play a central role in the hierarchy? Family, friends, colleagues, (if there are) children- their friends and associated families, the consistent interactions with others where we shop and relax. These aspects of life may be geographically close to ‘home’ or some distance away. This can apply to rural and urban locations – if the local school is now closed, the local council offices moved away, the bus service limited – then the patterns of consistent interactions are reduced and the foundations that formed communities previously – are also eroded.The digital tools of the modern world can further reduce the necessity for human interaction in everyday life, additionally limiting the ability for communities to form organically.

Within a heritage environment it can feel that communities are currently co-created. Created by people and by conflict. There are the obvious examples – the shared (whether through choice or circumstance) groups – of interest, locality or experience.

But that sense of ‘community’ seems to be co-created by circumstance. Often coalesced by reaction/resistance to external (or even internal) factors. Is community now purely defined by ‘the other’? Is formation occurring in order to gain an identity and get a voice?

Who is represented will always be subjective and whilst I’m not sure there will ever be a clear answer to this – if we start with the principle that individuals having a voice and being able to articulate that voice in all circumstances (be they positive, benign, or challenging) is key to enabling informed outcomes – can we now start talk about social voices, rather than a community?

Social voices brought together by – circumstance, locality, experiences, interests. It’s a reflection and expression of society – micro or macro. Community too often implies cohesion and agreement – which when manufactured will be fragile and ultimately contentious.

A society – that’s already fractious and contentious, but also driven by a need to continue.

It almost exists without definition.

Expecting and reflecting the different social voices found within a place will not be easy, but it might be a more honest way forward. When we reduce any group to a simple descriptor we reduce the expression of a variety of experiences. The term ‘housewife’ did little to express the variety of lives lived within the descriptor – perhaps the same is now true for ‘community’.

BACK

BEFS Director Euan Leitch asks, should politicians be influencing the final outcome of planning decisions?

Two recent planning decisions by Scottish Ministers are of note.

Ministers accepted the advice of their Reporter and refused consent for a large scale leisure and tourism development which included over 1000 houses and the consolidation of Loudon Castle, East Ayrshire. Permission was refused on the following grounds:

  • There is no certainty that the scale of proposed housing development is the minimum level required as enabling development.
  • The scale of the proposed enabling housing development would have an adverse impact on the Loudoun Castle Historic Garden and Designed Landscape.
  • The separation of the proposed tourism leisure proposals from the proposed housing for enabling funding purposes is not acceptable.
  • Furthermore, the scale of the proposed enabling housing development, and lack of suitable masterplanning mean that, in their present form, the proposals would not result in a well-planned sustainable community.

There is not an infrequent assumption that economics and housing numbers trump other planning matters such as heritage and sustainability, but in this case it is the converse. The full report, while lengthy, is worthy of further examination.

The other decision is in relation to the proposed expansion of Hyndford Quarry into the buffer zone of the New Lanark World Heritage Site. This has been a long running case and the Scottish Government Reporter found the western and southern expansion of quarry to be in line with policy and recommended that the proposals would:

  • Contribute to overcoming an identified shortfall in the minerals reserve (landbank);
  • Protect and preserve the character, integrity and quality of the New Lanark World Heritage Site, its setting and Outstanding Universal Value;
  • Avoid compromise to the integrity of the Falls of Clyde Designed Landscape, its character and the objectives of its designation;
  • Safeguard listed buildings, their settings, and any features of special interest they possess;
  • Preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the New Lanark and Falls of Clyde Conservation Area;
  • Protect scheduled ancient monuments and their settings;
  • Not adversely affect the overall quality of special landscape areas;
  • Not harm nature conservation interests;
  • Support sustainable economic development; and
  • Provide an acceptable restoration scheme.

For the western extension of the quarry Ministers found the opposite to be the case, that it contravened a range of regional and local planning policy, and are therefore only minded to grant permission for the southern extension of the quarry. The full report is again worth reading but raises similar questions as before around why East Ayrshire Council , Historic Environment Scotland and the Scottish Government Reporter are interpreting planning policy and heritage values so differently from Scottish Ministers?

As the Planning (Scotland) Bill has been progressing through parliamentary scrutiny, one repeated refrain has been on the topic of Ministerial intervention in the planning process, and the refrain is usually that it should be resisted. But is that wholly desirable? The thousands of people who objected to the Hyndford Quarry extension will be grateful for Ministerial intervention, but when Ministerial decisions go the other way there is usually disquiet expressed about their role. Perhaps we have to accept, or embrace, that planning is fundamentally political.

BACK