Get The Latest Historic Environment Events, Jobs, News And Publications In BEFS Bulletin.
BEFS NEWS
The Scottish local elections are taking place today and following BEFS support of hustings in Glasgow and Edinburgh it is evident that advocacy for the built environment will be needed. Hopefully the Advocacy Toolkit will prove a valuable resource and we will endeavour to share details of the key councillors in the coming weeks.
The Edinburgh International Book Festival is holding ReimagiNation in Cumbernauld from 19-21 May, a festival weekend bringing stories out of the shadows of the New Town’s infamous architecture. It looks like an interesting programme and will be visiting East Kilbride and Irvine later this year, and Glenrothes and Livingstone in 2018.
Historic Environment Scotland and Archaeology Scotland have announced the call for papers, speakers, displays and contributions to Scotland’s Community Heritage Conference 2017. Now in its sixth year, the Conference offers the opportunity for heritage volunteers and professionals to network, share experiences and create future working partnerships.
There are a number of interesting events and CPD opportunities coming up, which are featured in our events and training sections. There are also some great job opportunities, from Policy Officer at NTS to Traditional Skills Officer at Glasgow City Heritage Trust and Director at the Cockburn Association. Check out the vacancies section for information on how to apply.
In our first blog, BEFS newest Associate Member introduces himself and his company.
War Memorials Trust share with us their work and the recognition recently received for grant giving activities, in our second blog this week.
CONSULTATIONS
Call for Evidence on Homelessness (SP 03/05/17)
The Scottish Parliament’s Local Government and Communities Committee has today, Wednesday 3 May 2017, launched a call for written evidence on homelessness.
Reviewing the Edinburgh Design Guidance – your views (Edinburgh Planning 11/04/17)
The Edinburgh Design Guidance is being reviewed and we’d like your comments on the proposed changes. We are also holding two consultation workshops on the Design Guidance on Monday 15 May, in the City Chambers. If you would like to attend, please email us the following details to spatial.policy@edinburgh.gov.uk.
Consultation on the guidance will close on 2 June 2017.
CONSULTATION RESPONSES
Consultation on Raising Planning Fees. Analysis of consultation responses (SG 25/04/17)
An independent analysis of the consultation on raising planning fees prepared by Chris Thornton, Associate Director, Craigforth.
PUBLICATIONS
Infrastructure Investment Plan 2015 – Progress Report for 2016 (SG 26/04/17)
This annual report outlines key achievements over the course of 2016 and looks forward to developments in 2017 and beyond.
Scottish Vacant and Derelict Land Survey 2016 (SG 25/04/17)
The Scottish Vacant and Derelict Land Survey is a data collection undertaken to establish the extent and state of vacant and derelict land in Scotland.
SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT NEWS RELEASES
£8.35 million to support urban regeneration in the heart of Glasgow (SG 03/05/17)
New high quality office space and hundreds of jobs for the city centre. Housing Minister Kevin Stewart today announced investment of £8.35 million from its SPRUCE fund to support the refurbishment of vacant office space in central Glasgow.
Green home loans (SG 02/05/17)
Updated scheme cuts red tape for home-owners. Home-owners can now apply for an interest free loan of up to £32,500 to improve the energy efficiency and use of renewable technologies in their properties.
Personal Achievement in Planning (SG 04/17)
The Scottish Government is continuing the Personal Achievement in Planning Award this year. This Award is to recognise an individual planner, team, local authorities, consultants, community groups, developers, public agencies or voluntary organisation that have made an outstanding contribution to planning. All entries must be nominated by sending a completed Personal Achievement Nomination Form to saqp@gov.scot by the closing date, 19 May 2017.
Building for the future (SG 26/04/17)
£6.4 billion of infrastructure projects underway. Infrastructure projects worth almost £6.4 billion will be under construction throughout Scotland in 2017. Projects such as the Forth Valley College Falkirk Campus, NHS Orkney’s New Hospital and Healthcare Facilities and the A737 Dalry Bypass will all commence construction this year.
Decrease in derelict and urban vacant land 9SG 25/04/17)
A National Statistics Publication for Scotland. The total amount of derelict and urban vacant land in Scotland decreased by 253 hectares (two per cent) from the previous year, to 12,435 hectares in 2016.
NEWS RELEASES
2017 EU Prize for Cultural Heritage: Special Mentions (EN 01/05/17)
The Special Mentions of the European Union Prize for Cultural Heritage / Europa Nostra Awards 2017 were made public today by Europa Nostra and the European Commission. This year, the Awards’ Jury granted Special Mentions to 13 heritage achievements from 11 European countries taking part in the Creative Europe programme of the European Union.
Glasgow Traditional Building Skills Demonstration (STBF 28/04/17)
The Glasgow Traditional Building Forum organised a hugely successful traditional building skills demonstration on Buchanan Street, Glasgow on 24 & 25 April 2017.
Working update on diversity in Historic Environment Sector: HEF & Heritage 2020 (IHBC 26/04/17)
Members of England’s lead link heritage grouping, the Historic Environment Forum (HEF) and the working groups of the linked initiative Heritage 2020 recently came together to discuss diversity in the historic environment sector.
MyParkScotland History, Heritage & Archaeology crowdfund campaign (MPS 26/04/17)
2017 is the year of heritage, history and archaeology. To celebrate this, we have launched our Heritage and History campaign to promote the diversity of Scotland’s parks and greenspaces highlighting projects that are working to develop park and greenspace heritage.
Community ownership and local councils (SCVO 24/04/17)
In the final of our pre-local election blogs, Linsay Chalmers talks us through community land. 540,000 acres of land are now in community ownership in Scotland and 2017 could be the busiest ever year for community buyouts, with 187 applications currently in the pipeline for the Scottish Land Fund.
The local authority dilemma: engage in local climate action now, or wait? (RTPI 19/04/17)
Local climate action is not just about ‘climate change’ – it is about planning for the future of our places and communities. It is being ready for how the environment will change and engaging with this in a way that builds the liveable and healthy places that we want to live in, now and into the future. So why isn’t local climate action common place?
Tracking Scotland’s changing landscape (SNH 12/04/17)
A new way of tracking and reporting on Scotland’s ever-changing landscapes has been launched today (Wednesday) by Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH). Scotland’s Landscape Monitoring Programme (LMP) is accessible on SNH’s website allowing anyone to follow how our dynamic landscapes change over the years.
Designing mental health into cities: the next frontier for urban design (DC 12/04/17)
If city-makers are to address mental health through urban design, where should they start? Layla McCay, the Director of Centre for Urban Design and Mental health, explains the reasons that city-dwellers are at greater risk of mental health problems and shows how urban design can support better mental health.
Heritage Lottery Fund statement – funding for places of worship (HLF 04/17)
The Heritage Lottery Fund (HLF) is changing the way it funds places of worship. Time and resource-stretched congregations have been telling us that they want to access our funding more easily, so we are bringing in a more flexible and lighter-touch way of distributing much-needed funding support from the National Lottery.
MEMBERS NEWS
RTPI Scotland thinkpieces – Proposals for change (RTPI 02/05/17)
The Scottish Government consultation paper Places, People and Planning contains many ideas for making the planning system more influential and effective. Working groups of RTPI Scotland committee members have now come together to prepare a series of thinkpieces that advance some of these ideas into implementable changes that could make a major impact on how our planning system works.
Project of the Year: RICS Awards, Scotland (RICS 27/04/17)
We’re delighted to announce our Project of the Year, the £35 million refurbishment of Glasgow’s Kelvin Hall, and the other eight category winners for the RICS Awards, Scotland. Over 35 of Scotland’s most impressive and community beneficial property schemes battled it out for top honours at the prestigious 2017 RICS Awards, Scotland. BBC news reader Catriona Shearer hosted the sell-out ceremony, held at Edinburgh’s luxurious Sheraton Hotel, which attracted more than 200 local property professionals.
Should we have a statutory chief planning officer in local authorities? (RTPI 26/04/17)
We need to make sure that strategic decisions taken by local authorities and Community Planning Partnerships are not taken in isolation. The implications of new investment and new development need to be assessed and planned for. Given this, in a thinkpiece published today by RTPI Scotland proposes that the forthcoming Planning Bill establishes a statutory Chief Planning Officer (CPO) in each local authority.
IHBC welcomes BEFS’ success in new NPF heritage measures: Critical disrepair in pre-1919 dwellings (IHBC 22/04/17)
The IHBC has welcomed the announcement by Built Environment Forum Scotland (BEFS) that, following active engagement with the Scottish Government and across is members, a new National Performance Framework (NPF) measure for the historic environment has been adopted, the percentage of pre-1919 dwellings classified as having disrepair to critical elements.
Guidelines for Cultural Heritage Impact Assessment (IHBC 19/04/17)
The IHBC is teaming up with the Chartered Institute for Archaeologists (CIfA) and the Institute of Environmental Management and Assessment (IEMA) to produce a guidance document for cultural heritage impact assessment (GCHIA), and develop guidance as authoritative as the Guidelines for Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment (GLVIA) has been in its sphere.
Heritage Hustings (EWH 19/04/17)
Against the historic backdrop of St. Stephen’s Stockbridge, one of the largest audiences yet seen for a local government hustings in the city debated a range of issues yesterday evening with representatives of all five parties. Subjects raised included the impact of ‘brash’ new development, the consequences of unregulated Airbnb holiday lets, the proposed ‘tourist tax’ and the growth of student accommodation in the city centre.
PARLIAMENTARY QUESTIONS
Questions marked with a triangle (?) are initiated by the Scottish Government in order to facilitate the provision of information to the Parliament.Questions in which a member has indicated a declarable interest are marked with an “R”.
S5W-08883 Pauline McNeill: To ask the Scottish Government when it will publish the findings of its research into barriers to engagement and the role of community councils in planning. (SP 21/04/17)
S5O-00900 John Finnie: To ask the Scottish Government what value it places on locations in Scotland
holding UNESCO World Heritage Site status. (SP 20/04/17)
PARLIAMENTARY QUESTIONS & ANSWERS
Questions marked with a triangle (?) are initiated by the Government in order to facilitate the provision of information to the Parliament.
Question S5W-08477: Christine Grahame, Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale, Scottish National Party, Date Lodged: 29/03/2017
To ask the Scottish Government what measures are in place to require an assessment of services, such as schools, public transport and medical facilities, to take place as a condition of planning consents for housing developments.
Answered by Kevin Stewart (19/04/2017)
Question S5W-08476: Christine Grahame, Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale, Scottish National Party, Date Lodged: 29/03/2017
To ask the Scottish Government what measures are in place to permit the compulsory purchase of vacant commercial premises in town centres for the purpose of redeveloping them for social housing.
Answered by Kevin Stewart (18/04/2017)
Question S5W-08573: Anas Sarwar, Glasgow, Scottish Labour, Date Lodged: 03/04/2017
To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking to tackle the issue of damp homes in the (a) private and (b) owner-occupied sector.
Answered by Kevin Stewart (18/04/2017)
Question S5W-08676: Maurice Golden, West Scotland, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date Lodged: 05/04/2017
To ask the Scottish Government what modelling it has undertaken of maximising solar energy capture in new housing developments to assess the potential (a) financial benefits to homeowners and (b) wider economic and societal benefits.
Answered by Kevin Stewart (18/04/2017)
Question S5W-08675: Maurice Golden, West Scotland, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date Lodged: 05/04/2017
To ask the Scottish Government what research it has carried out on the long-term value of resource efficient building in the housing sector.
Answered by Kevin Stewart (24/04/2017)
Question S5W-08674: Maurice Golden, West Scotland, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date Lodged: 05/04/2017
To ask the Scottish Government how many electric vehicle charging points have been included in new housing developments since its Scottish Planning Policy was published in 2014.
Answered by Kevin Stewart (18/04/2017)
DEBATES
UNESCO World Heritage Sites
John Finnie (Highlands and Islands) (Green):
To ask the Scottish Government what value it places on locations in Scotland holding UNESCO world heritage site status. (S5O-00900)
The Cabinet Secretary for Culture, Tourism and External Affairs (Fiona Hyslop):
The Scottish Government attaches great value to UNESCO world heritage site status. We are in the year of history, heritage and archaeology. On world heritage day, I took part in an event that celebrated the importance of one of our six world heritage sites—the Antonine wall, at which Picts and Romans were in evidence. There was even a great Roman bake-off. Using innovative and creative ways not just to preserve and conserve our heritage sites but to make them inviting places for people to visit is very important. Read the full transcript
MOTIONS
S5M-05185 Keith Brown: Defence Basing Reforms and the Impact on Scotland—That the Parliament expresses concern about the impact on Scotland of the military base closures announced by the Ministry of Defence as part of its Estate Optimisation Strategy; supports local community opposition to closures, and calls on the UK Government to engage fully with the Scottish Government, local authorities and local communities as a matter of urgency.
Supported by: Jamie Hepburn, Paul Wheelhouse (SP 20/04/17)
*S5M-05259 Gail Ross: RIAS Awards 2017—That the Parliament congratulates all the nominees for the Royal Incorporation of Architects in Scotland (RIAS) Awards 2017, which comprise of buildings and projects throughout the length and breadth of the country; notes in particular the inclusion of Fernaig Cottage in Wester Ross, which saw the restoration and adaptation of a former shepherd’s longhouse, the newly-completed Noss Primary School in Wick and the conversion of the disused Corrie Church on the shores of Loch Torridon; wishes all on the shortlist the best of luck in the finals, and recognises what it believes is the incredible innovation and design in current Scottish architecture.
Supported by: Jenny Gilruth*, Emma Harper*, Ross Thomson*, Tavish Scott*, Gillian Martin*, Ben Macpherson*, Sandra White*, Alexander Burnett*, Graeme Dey*, Bill Kidd*, Stuart McMillan*, Richard Lyle* (SP 21/04/17)
EVENTS
For the latest information about BEFS Members’ events see our events calendar.
Afternoon lecture by Margaret Stewart: Landscaping the Nation, Lord Mar’s Designs c1700-1730 to follow Scotland’s Garden & Landscape Heritage AGM
When: Saturday, 6 May: AGM 12pm; Lunch 1pm – 1.45pm; Lecture 2pm; Walk 3.30pm.
Where: Alloa Tower, Alloa Park, Alloa FK10 1PP.
Dr Margaret Stewart’s talk offers a unique opportunity to hear the story behind this visionary design from the leading authority on the subject. The lecture will be followed by a guided walk to discover what still remains of the eighteenth-century landscape. The number of places at the lecture is restricted, so you are advised to book online in advance.
STP Place Branding & Communications Workshop
When: May 16, 2017 at 1:30pm – 4pm.
Where: Architecture & Design Scotland, Edinburgh.
Hear from media experts and local case studies that will leave you feeling equipped and inspired to find your town’s USP, grab the headlines, or make a cutting-edge film. Get top tips from Morrison Media Strategies, Newsquest Media Group, Enterprise Screen, Explore Largs BID, and Scotland’s Towns Partnership. Network over refreshments with town stakeholders from diverse sectors, and discuss strategies for your town. Don’t miss out – book today!
Sacred Heritage: Archaeology, Identity and Medieval Beliefs – Rhind Lectures
When: May 19 @ 6:00 pm – May 21 @ 5:00 pm.
Where: Auditorium National Museum Scotland, Edinburgh.
Medieval churches and monasteries are key features of the British landscape, contributing to local identities and sense of place. Yet the relationship between heritage and medieval religion has received relatively little critical reflection. These lectures will place research on medieval beliefs within a wider framework of sacred heritage, reflecting on issues of value, authenticity and interpretation. The lectures develop chronologically from the 12th century to the use of archaeology today, with case studies focusing on Scottish monasticism and Glastonbury Abbey.
Sustainable Futures for Traditional Buildings
When: Thursday 25th May 2017 from 9.30am.
Where: The Haining, Selkirk.
In recent years a number of ‘at risk’ buildings have become the subject of high profile ‘Heritage Rescue’ operations resulting in their successful adaptation to a range of alternative uses. For each of these ‘Success Stories’ there are many other buildings which at present face an uncertain future. The Scottish Traditional Skills Training Centre in association with Selkirk Conservation Area Regeneration Scheme (CARS) has brought together 4 leading experts to look at the basic principles and critical factors which must be addressed when identifying potential sustainable futures for a range of traditional buildings. The cost of the event is £35 (Heavily subsidised by Selkirk CARS) and includes buffet lunch and tea/coffee.
Archaeological Research in Progress 2017
When: 27 May 2017.
Where: National Museums Scotland Auditorium, Edinburgh, EH1 1JF.
The Society is hosting the 2017 ARP conference, the national conference examining recent and ongoing archaeological projects across Scotland. Please book online or phone 0131 247 4133. Tickets £35 for Fellows, Archaeology Scotland members and students. £40 full price.
RIAS Spring Seminar – More Conservation Challenges
When: 31 May 2017 from 1pm – 5pm.
Where: The Scottish Storytelling Centre, Edinburgh.
The RIAS conservation spring seminar is now open for bookings. Chaired by RIAS Secretary, Neil Baxter, topics will include conservation work at the Capitol, Washington DC, and the Scottish architectural legacy in India. The technical components will include climate change adaptation for traditional buildings, interpreting thermal imaging and advice on working with lime for pointing and harling, including specification advice and guidance on the causes of failure, 3D laser scanning technique as used in the restoration of Glasgow School of Art.
Gordon Barr and Gary Painter: Glasgow’s Cinema Experiment
When: 7 June 2017, 7-9pm
Where: GCHT, 54 Bell Street, Glasgow
Scotland has some of the most architecturally diverse cinema buildings of anywhere in the world. This double-act led talk will cover the full range of Glasgow’s cinema history, from converted roller-skating rinks, via the earliest purpose built halls, the peculiarly Scottish ‘back-court’ theatres, to the finest thirties art deco super-cinemas, stopping off to highlight some of the most interesting depictions of Glasgow on screen, both as itself and pretending to be other cities along the way.
Sir Patrick Geddes Commemorative Lecture 2017 – Poverty, Places and Equality: A role for place based approaches?
When: Wednesday, 07 June 2017 at 5:45PM – 8:15PM.
Where: The Lighthouse, Mitchell Lane, Glasgow G1 3NU.
Naomi Eisenstadt – Independent Advisor to the Scottish Government on Poverty and Inequalit.y
After a long career in the NGO sector, in 1999 Naomi became the first Director of the Sure Start Unit. The Unit was responsible for delivering the government’s commitment to free nursery education places for all 3-4 year olds, the national childcare strategy, and reducing the gap in outcomes between children living in disadvantaged areas and the wider child population. Naomi spent 3 years as the Director of the Social Exclusion Task Force working across government to identify and promote policies to address the needs of traditionally excluded groups. Since retiring from the Civil Service, Naomi has chaired the Camden Equalities Commission, the Milton Keynes Child Poverty Commission, published a book and several articles relevant to child development and child poverty.
The City Talks: Conservation v Evolution? Do conservation areas hold back or encourage positive development?
When: 14 June 2017, 7-9pm
Where: GCHT, 54 Bell Street, Glasgow
We all agree that the protection and enhancement of Scotland’s conservation areas are important although some of us may be concerned that this statutory requirement of local authorities is not being met in many cases. However, as pressure increases to build in urban areas, might there by a case for a loosening of some of the restrictions that planning law places on new developments in and around conservation areas? Is heritage management compatible with innovative and bold modern architecture? Are we stifling creativity and radical design by holding onto long-cherished heritage principles? These are just some of the issues our panel of experts will be discussing.
IHBC Annual School: Transport Infrastructure – the backbone of civilisation
When: Thursday 22nd – Saturday 24th June 2017. Day School – Friday 23rd June 2017.
Where: Manchester.
The 2017 IHBC Annual School examines the rich legacy of transport infrastructure, exploring both its continuing role as a future driver of change and economic growth as well as its impact upon historic places. The Annual School includes three exciting days of lectures, networking and practical learning to share skills, knowledge and understanding; tours exploring all facets of historic and new infrastructure and its impact on the historic environment around Manchester and the North; NETWORKING EVENTS; EVENING RECEPTION & IHBC ANNUAL DINNER with opportunities to pause, take stock and stimulate debate in fascinating venues.
TRAINING
Resourcing Scotland’s Heritage is delivering a series of training courses and events across Scotland. Our training is best suited to registered charities and constituted community groups. Here are the upcoming dates:
• , Wed. 10th May, Edinburgh – Arts & Business Scotland
• , Wed. 17th May, Galashiels – Old Gala
• , Wed. 24th May, Glasgow – Betty’s Room
• , Wed. 31st May, Aberdeen – Aberdeen Science Centre
The Damp in Buildings Masterclass
When: 19 May 2017, 09.30 – 16.30.
Where: Charlestown Workshops, Fife
Cost: £190 + vat. If you are a BLF, IHBC, RIBA or RIAS member you are eligible for 20% discount on this seminar. Please just give us a call with your member number. We are pleased to welcome back Mike Parrett, one of the world’s leading building pathologists and co-author of the RICS’ bestselling book ‘Diagnosing Damp’, recognised as the primary reference work on dampness in buildings.
CPD: Traditional Shopfronts
When: Tuesday 30th May 2017 | 12-1pm.
Where: Glasgow City Heritage Trust, 54 Bell Street, Glasgow.
Shopfronts have a huge impact on the quality of our civic spaces and are a key component of a vibrant town centre. Dr Lindsay Lennie, historic shopfront expert, will be looking at the key elements forming a traditional shopfront, the materials and construction techniques as they relate to different periods in retail architecture. Lindsay is a chartered surveyor with a diploma in building conservation and a PhD in historic shopfronts.
VACANCIES
Policy Officer – Permanent / part-time (NTS)
This job exists to develop and communicate Trust policy in order to guide conservation and visitor management practice. In addition, the post-holder will contribute to the Trusts role as an advocate for the conservation of Scotlands heritage, and for access, learning and enjoyment of that heritage.
Closing date: Friday 12 May 2017.
Traditional Skills Officer (GCHT)
An exciting opportunity has become available to support the implementation of the Trust’s traditional skills and materials programme for the benefit of all people living in, working in and visiting Glasgow. Through events, training sessions, public engagement activities and partnerships you will deliver a programme of traditional skills training and educational activities targeting contractors, craftspeople, professionals, communities and homeowners to train and educate those responsible for the upkeep of Glasgow’s built heritage, encourage best practice, and showcase career opportunities in the heritage and construction sectors.
Deadline for applications: Friday 12th May 2017.
CARS Project Officer
Dunoon Conservation Area Regeneration Scheme (CARS) is a £1.8M heritage-led partnership project between Argyll and Bute Council, Historic Environment Scotland and LEADER. The postholder is required to project manage and fully deliver Dunoon CARS, and to do this over a 5-year period whilst ensuring that the project is delivered on time and within budget. The project focusses on Dunoon’s principal shopping street, Argyll Street and includes funding towards shopfront repairs as well as the comprehensive restoration of 4 tenements. It is anticipated that the postholder will be experienced with working on historic environment projects.
Closes: Friday, 12th May 2017.
Fundraising Vacancy – Part time (Archaeology Scotland)
We are looking for someone to help with both Trusts Fundraising and Events Co-ordination. This is part-time post (15 hours), fixed term until June 2019. If you have the relevant experience and bags of enthusiasm please apply with a covering letter and CV to e.macqueen@archaeologyscotland.org.uk.
Closing date 12 May 2017.
Director Post (Cockburn Association)
The Cockburn Association is now looking for a Director who has the leadership skills and capability to monitor and implement its strategy. The ideal candidate will be highly motivated and enthusiastic about the Cockburn Association activities and campaigns. He/She will have the capacity to lead and deliver the key activities of the Association, working with allies, strengthening the membership base, and broadening the constituency of ‘those who love Edinburgh’ through awareness and education. In doing so he/she will take account of the advice in the 2015 Strategy that the Association should focus on doing less in more depth, concentrate on activities which have the potential to make a difference and ensure that the scope of our work is realistic in terms of our time and financial resources. For more information on the role, please contact Joe Taylor on 0131 557 8686 (email admin@cockburnassociation.org.uk) or for a confidential discussion please contact the Vice-Chair of the Association, Andrew MacLeod at 0131 667 5663.
Closing date: 26th May 2017.
Director of Development and Partnership (HES)
This is a new senior post, reporting directly to the Chief Executive, with responsibility for driving forward a range of strategic developments vital to the future work of HES and the wider sector. Please note that this post will also attract a £1,500 on call allowance and 5% Directors allowance. You will identify and explore the big issues and questions for Scotland’s historic environment, both now and in the future. You will lead HES engagement with partners and stakeholders, take forward new areas of work and coordinate work strands across the organisation. You will provide leadership and foresight both for HES and the historic environment sector including, as lead Director responsible for the delivery of Our Place in Time, the historic environment strategy for Scotland. You will bring knowledge of the sector, strong policy and partnership skills, fresh thinking and a strong customer focus to HES.
Closing Date: 26 May 2017 at midday.
BACK
War Memorials Trust Share With Us Their Work And The Recognition Recently Received For Grant Giving Activities

Kirkintilloch War Memorial
The protection and conservation of war memorials is the focus for charity War Memorials Trust which was formed in 1997. There are estimated to be over 100,000 war memorials in the UK. Many of these are treasured but sadly others are neglected and vandalised or left to suffer the effects of ageing and weathering. To help combat this the Trust provide free advice and information to anyone as well as administering grant schemes for the repair and conservation of war memorials. The charity has also developed a youth focused Learning Programme to educate young people in schools and youth groups about their war memorial heritage.
In Scotland the Trust administers the Centenary Memorials Restoration Fund (CMRF) on behalf of Historic Environment Scotland and the Scottish Government. £1 million is available, up until March 2018, to help communities undertake repair and conservation works to war memorials. Underpinning the grant scheme is best conservation practice; ensuring that any works supported are appropriate to the memorial, in-line with methods that will minimise any potential damage and offer the greatest chance of supporting long-term preservation.
Four years into the scheme, the CMRF has awarded 99 grants totalling £783,000. So whilst funding remains we are encouraging people to get their applications in quickly to secure a share. The scale of grants varies considerably. The Fintry Kirk stained glass window in Stirling was awarded a grant of £430. Due to exposure to weathering there was a build-up of dirt on the memorial stained glass window. A small number of stained glass panes were cracked or damaged. In addition, the exterior protective glazing has been damaged and the joints in the surrounding stone mullions had cracked. To address these issues work was undertaken to clean and repair the stained glass window. Like-for-like replacements of areas of the protective glazing was undertaken while the joints in the stone mullions were re-pointed with a lime based mortar.
At the other end of the scale Kirkintilloch war memorial in East Dunbartonshire was awarded a grant of £57,240. The inappropriate cementitious mortar pointing had severely deteriorated and was causing a number of conservation issues for the masonry including water ingress, plant growth and areas of gypsum deposits gathered on the marble cladding. The pointing that did remain was stained and unsightly. Some of the masonry was damaged, including severe cracks, and some previous repairs had failed. The cast iron gates showed signs of corrosion. The marble cladding had gathered superficial surface grime while the bronze plaques were weathered and dull in appearance. To address these issues a thorough appraisal of the condition of the memorial was undertaken and a programme of works drawn up. Repair and, where necessary, replacement was undertaken to the marble, the failed mortar was carefully raked out across the memorial and then re-pointed using a lime mortar. Vegetation was removed and the stone cleaned. Repairs were undertaken to the stone copes and leadwork while the bronze elements and iron work were cleaned and treated.
Grant giving has been central to War Memorials Trust’s efforts since the charity began, therefore in the 20th anniversary of the foundation of the charity, it was wonderful to receive recognition for this work. On 23rd February 2017 the Trust was awarded the Directory of Social Change Great Giving Funders Award, voted for by the public. The award recognised funders which demonstrate a clear understanding of their beneficiaries and the funding environment and are committed to improving grant making by giving clear guidance and support. That description outlines exactly what we aim to do!
BACK
Historic Environment Scotland and Archaeology Scotland announce a call for contributions to Scotland’s Community Heritage Conference 2017.
Now in its sixth year, Scotland’s Community Heritage Conference is a unique annual event within the UK that offers the opportunity for heritage volunteers and professionals to network, share experiences and create future working partnerships.
To celebrate Scotland’s Year of History, Heritage and Archaeology, this year’s conference will be a two-day event, with two key aims:
- To showcase the exemplar work of community-led heritage in Scotland, the UK and beyond – both of individual projects and of wider initiatives
- To learn from community-based best practice outside Scotland
We are keen to hear from you about your involvement with community heritage, and this year are inviting contributions from both community volunteers and professionals. The emphasis, as always, will be on providing a forum for networking and the exchange of news and ideas. To get an idea of previous conferences, why not take a look at some of our previous presentations on YouTube.
For more information, please contact the team at chcscot@gmail.com or submit an abstract by Tuesday 30th May 2017.
BACK
BEFS newest Associate Member introduces himself and his company.
I’m David McAllister, managing Director of Craigerne Consulting Limited, based in Peebles in the Scottish Borders. I have set up this new business following a period of sixteen successful years in various roles with the National Trust for Scotland. I’m a highly experienced professional with a total of over 30 years in the Heritage sector focussed on Conservation and Operational management and skilled in the planning and delivery of successful, award winning heritage projects. I am now taking opportunities to bring my expertise to a wider and more diversified Client base.
I have a deep passion for our entire heritage and have well developed understanding of all the complexities, opportunities and constraints that are always the fundamental elements of Heritage, Conservation and Cultural projects. Also, with over 7 years as a member of the NTS Senior Management Team I have the experience of managing an extensive portfolio of highly significant heritage assets in a climate of considerable change.
I believe his combination of experience makes me a considerable asset for the planning and execution of successful projects in the Heritage, Conservation and Cultural Sectors.
See more about the services I offer on my website: www.craigerne-consulting.com
Current Activity
I’m currently working on a Visitor Improvement Plan for the Bo’ness Motor Museum. This is focusing on the wonderfully unique and at times quirky collection of 20th century cars and associated memorabilia the museum has collected over the years, many associated with film and television – so all very much recent cultural heritage here! The James Bond collection is particularly noteworthy as is the Harry Potter Ford Anglia. The work involves setting out short, medium and longer-term actions for the team to implement that will boost visitor numbers and improve visitor experience.
We are also exploring a new website and expanding on social media content to promote collections, activities and engage with new audiences.
Hospitalfield Arts, Arbroath
As a Trustee and Chair of the Development Committee at Hospitalfield for the ambitious Future Plan it is an exciting time with our Stage 2 HLF application in for approval hopefully later in the year. It is an ongoing pleasure to be involved in such a worthwhile and vibrant project!
Project Funding approval from Creative Scotland is expected soon and we are one of the key capital projects included in the Tay Cities Deal proposals currently under consideration.
Phase 1 of the project includes a new residential block by Stirling Prize winners Caruso St John, the restoration of the old Glasshouse and Fernery, bringing these back into public use. The latest addition to the scheme is the exciting proposal for the garden by Nigel Dunnet, which we are delighted with and we believe, will bring new audiences to Hospitalfield for the first time. Hospitalfield is dedicated to contemporary art and ideas a place to work, study, learn, visit and enjoy.
See more at: http://hospitalfield.org.uk/about/future-plan/
Two Cities
I have been fortunate to visit two World Heritage Cities in recent weeks, Bologna and Hamburg. This is the reason I was unable to attend the Financing the Historic Environment conference in Glasgow, which I’m sad to have missed as it looks to have been a great success with insightful presentations and discussions. Hopefully next year I will be better organised.
Here are some impressions from Bologna, a truly inspiring city that don’t need more words to describe. Make a point of visiting if you have not been before, ther is wonderful artwork everywhere you look!
Hamburg is also well worth the visit, particularly to see the outstanding conservation/transformation underway in the Halfencity district, but for the purposes of this blog I wanted to focus on just one building. The Elbphilharmonie by Herzog & De Meuron -arguably a building that is redefining a city.
Not without controversy (the cost overrun puts the Scottish Parliament in the shade and is still a very hot topic in the city). This is an astonishing, awe inspiring building all the more remarkable in that it is an adaptation and extension (and what an extension) of an original brick warehouse in the heart of the old docks.
Hamburg now has an unmistakable new landmark on the city skyline.
The guidebook talks of its silhouette as a …’symbol of Germany as a nation of culture. A symphony of beauty, an ode to the future’ I don’t disagree.
Finally a plug for a couple of upcoming events focused on Grandison & Son Decorative Plasterers– one of the last remaining plastering workshops in Scotland, and how their wonderful collection of moulds and casts will be at risk once the current proprietor retires in around 10 years’ time. Over the past few months a small group of us have been working on ways of securing the future of this unique business and plasterwork museum based in Peebles and with the grateful assistance of Live Borders are happy to announce two upcoming events planned to increase awareness of the collection, which we hope one day will be recognised as a collection of national significance in its own right.
Get The Latest Historic Environment Events, Jobs, News And Publications In BEFS Bulletin.
BEFS NEWS
The new National Performance Framework indicator measure for historic sites is now live on the Scotland Performs website. For background information on why the indicator was changed read our recommendation to the Scottish Government from 2016.
Ahead of the local government elections, we would like to draw your attention to a recently published book. The Public Affairs Guide to Scotland is an essential A-Z guide for all public, private and third sector policy and corporate organisations in Scotland.
In the last week Built Environment Forum Scotland has supported hustings in Glasgow and Edinburgh with a focus on the built environment. BEFS Director, Euan Leitch, reflects on what was learnt in our first blog.
The second of our blogs this week offers a great case study for communities taking action in their local built environment.
Finally, book now for Scottish Civic Trust’s annual lecture on Glasgow’s Merchant City on 25th April, supported by BEFS.
CONSULTATIONS
Energy efficiency and condition standards in private rented housing: A Scotland’s Energy Efficiency Programme Consultation (SG 07/04/17)
This consultation asks for views on proposals to improve the energy efficiency and condition standards in privately rented housing in Scotland.
Closes 30 Jun 2017.
Draft Management Plan for the Old and New Towns of Edinburgh World Heritage Site (2017-2022) (Edinburgh City Council, HES & EWH)
The Draft Management Plan identifies issues and opportunities within the Site, and presents an action plan for implementation over a five-year period. Issues include care and maintenance of buildings and streets and awareness of World Heritage Site status.
PUBLICATIONS
Minimum Standards of Energy Efficiency in Private Rented Sector Housing: Partial Business and Regulatory Impact Assessment (SG 07/04/17)
This partial BRIA accompanies part 1 of the Scottish Government consultation on efficiency and condition standards in private rented housing. It provides an assessment of the impact of the proposed regulation on various parties and sectors within the Scottish economy. The analysis and data may also help readers in responding to the consultation.
Condition of Private Rented Housing in Scotland – Business and Regulatory Impact Assessment (partial) (SG 07/04/17)
This partial BRIA accompanies part 2 of the Scottish Government consultation on energy efficiency and condition standards in private rented housing. The data provided will help readers assess the impact of proposed changes to the repairing standard which applies to privately rented houses in Scotland.
CDAS Booklet on ‘How Community Development Happens’
The Community Development Alliance Scotland has published a new booklet called ‘How Community Development Happens: Why stronger communities matter and what it takes to develop them’.
SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT PRESS RELEASES
Household numbers projected to rise in Scotland’s National Parks and around its biggest cities (SG 12/04/17)
Figures published today by the National Records of Scotland (NRS) show that the number of households is projected to rise around Scotland’s biggest cities, and within its two National Parks.
VisitScotland and TripAdvisor team up to put Scotland on world stage (SG 08/04/17)
A European-first collaboration between VisitScotland and TripAdvisor will see Scotland’s world-class tourism offering promoted to almost 70 million new potential visitors, generating a potential additional spend of £150 million.
Improving Scotland’s private rented sector properties (SG 07/04/17)
Consultation on energy efficiency and condition standards. New proposals to ensure all privately rented homes in Scotland meet a minimum standard of energy efficiency have been published today for consultation.
NEWS RELEASES
Kilmarnock Traditional Building Skills Demonstration (STBF 18/04/17)
The Fife & Tayside Traditional Building Forum organised an event in Kirkcaldy town centre 13 & 14 March 2017, which featured apprentices, qualified tradespersons and college lecturers demonstrating traditional building skills including masonry, slate roofing, joinery and painting and decorating.
Culross Traditional Building Skills Event (STBF 18/04/17)
The Fife & Tayside Traditional Building Forum organised an event at the National Trust for Scotland property of Culross Palace on 20 & 21 March 2017, which featured apprentices demonstrating traditional building skills including masonry, slate roofing, joinery and plastering.
HES Unveils Plan for Year Ahead (HES 13/04/17)
Historic Environment Scotland (HES) has published its Annual Operating Plan for 2017/18. The plan outlines the organisation’s priorities under five strategic themes: Lead, Understand, Protect, Value and Perform.
Specialist skills shortage could put beloved national treasures into disrepair (RICS 12/04/17)
Britain’s beloved historic buildings are at risk, due to a restoration skills crisis that threatens the future of some of our best-known national treasures, warns a RICS and YouGov survey.
UN Security Council adopts historic resolution for the protection of heritage (IHBC 12/04/17)
The United Nations Security Council has unanimously adopted the historic resolution 2347 – the first ever resolution adopted by the Security Council to focus on Cultural heritage. The unanimous support to the Resolution reflects a new recognition of the importance of heritage protection for peace and security.
EU Prize for Cultural Heritage / Europa Nostra Award 2017 for Scottish project SAMPHIRE (SCT 05/04/17)
The 29 laureates from 18 countries are being recognised for their notable achievements in conservation, research, dedicated service, and education, training and awareness-raising.Among this year’s winners are two outstanding projects from the United Kingdom: the rehabilitation of Cromford Mills: Building 17, Derbyshire; and SAMPHIRE: Maritime heritage project in western Scotland.
Culture Secretary launches new fund to promote Scottish arts, heritage and business collaboration (Arts & Business Scotland 03/04/17)
A pioneering new fund that promotes collaboration between Scottish businesses and arts and heritage organisations to deliver new arts and heritage projects has been officially launched by Cabinet Secretary for Culture, Tourism and External Affairs Fiona Hyslop.
PARLIAMENTARY QUESTIONS
Questions marked with a triangle (?) are initiated by the Scottish Government in order to facilitate the provision of information to the Parliament.Questions in which a member has indicated a declarable interest are marked with an “R”.
S5W-08764 Maurice Golden: To ask the Scottish Government what plans it has to (a) review and (b) regulate speculative land purchasing practices to obtain planning permission on greenbelt and agricultural land (SP 18/04/17)
S5W-08573 Anas Sarwar: To ask the Scottish Government what action it is taking to tackle the issue of damp homes in the (a) private and (b) owner-occupied sector. (SP 10/04/17)
S5W-08674 Maurice Golden: To ask the Scottish Government how many electric vehicle charging points have been included in new housing developments since its Scottish Planning Policy was published in 2014. (SP 10/04/17)
S5W-08675 Maurice Golden: To ask the Scottish Government what research it has carried out on the long-term value of resource efficient building in the housing sector. (SP 10/04/17)
S5W-08676 Maurice Golden: To ask the Scottish Government what modelling it has undertaken of maximising solar energy capture in new housing developments to assess the potential (a) financial benefits to homeowners and (b) wider economic and societal benefits. (SP 10/04/17)
MOTIONS
Motion S5M-05059: Maree Todd, Highlands and Islands, Scottish National Party, Date Lodged: 05/04/2017
Lews Castle
That the Parliament congratulates Lews Castle in the Western Isles on it winning the Channel 4 Great British Buildings competition; understands that it has also been shortlisted for the Great British Buildings Restoration of the Year, a competition that is organised by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors; recognises the significance to the heritage of the Western Isles of restoring this important building; believes that the restoration will also have a positive impact on the area’s economy, and commends everyone involved with the restoration process.
Supported by: Bill Kidd, Joan McAlpine, Alexander Stewart, Douglas Ross, Kenneth Gibson, Donald Cameron, Sandra White, Emma Harper, Stuart McMillan, Richard Lyle, Ben Macpherson, Gillian Martin, Tom Arthur, Fulton MacGregor, David Torrance, Ivan McKee, Jackson Carlaw, Gil Paterson
Motion S5M-05043: Gordon Lindhurst, Lothian, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date Lodged: 04/04/2017
Consultation Open on Draft Management Plan for Edinburgh World Heritage Site
That the Parliament welcomes the opening of the public consultation on the third Old and New Towns of Edinburgh World Heritage Site Draft Management Plan (2017 to 2022); understands that the plan was drafted by the City of Edinburgh Council, Edinburgh World Heritage and Historic Environment Scotland following an initial consultation on its contents during the summer of 2016, which generated more than 1,000 responses; recognises the requirement for World Heritage Sites to produce such plans explaining how obligations under the World Heritage Site Convention are being met through the protection of its Outstanding Universal Value; understands that the draft plan focusses on the six key themes that scored lowest in the place standard and environmental quality indicators for the site; notes that further public consultation on the draft plan will run from 3 April to 5 June 2017, and encourages members of the public, as well as all interested stakeholders, to get involved.
Supported by: Peter Chapman, Alexander Stewart, Alison Harris, Liam Kerr, John Lamont, Edward Mountain, Maurice Corry, Alex Cole-Hamilton, Donald Cameron, Douglas Ross, Miles Briggs, Oliver Mundell, Jeremy Balfour, Alexander Burnett, Ross Thomson, Andy Wightman, Bill Bowman, Dean Lockhart, Liz Smith
EVENTS
For the latest information about BEFS Members’ events see our events calendar.
Scottish Civic Trust Annual Lecture 2017
When: Tue 25 April 2017 from 17:30 – 19:30.
Where: Scottish Storytelling Centre, 43-45 High Street, Edinburgh EH1 1SR.
Merchant City, one of Glasgow’s most historic areas has experienced many changes in its time, so much so that on more than one occasion it almost disappeared from the face of the earth. Its renaissance in more recent years has become part of the city’s folklore – but the story is not over yet! We will explore how we arrived at the present, and look at some of the issues for the future.
This lecture by architect and historian David Martin is part of a series of events which celebrate, in 2017, the 50th anniversary of both the inaugural meeting of the Scottish Civic Trust and the passing of the Civic Amenities Act 1967 which introduced the concept of conservation areas.
BRICK Workshop 27
When: 9th May, 9:30 am – 4:30 pm.
Where: The Grange Court, Pinsley Road, – Leominster
Our 27th BRICK workshop will take place on 9th May 2017 in Grange Court, Pinsley Road, Leominster, Herefordshire, HR6 8NL. The day will focus on governance, project management as it relates to the project objectives of groups involved in heritage regeneration and using and understanding your Quantity Surveyor. These relevant topics are part of the Prince’s Regeneration Trust’s efforts to help with ensuring a sustainable future for historic buildings and sites. This event will also serve as a networking opportunity for community groups and not-for-profit organisations.
Central Scotland Green Network Forum – How green infrastructure is transforming the way we live
When: 15th June 2017 from 09:00 – 16:30.
Where: John McIntyre Conference Facility, Pollock Halls, 18 Holyrood Park Road, Edinburgh.
This year’s Forum, our seventh, provides an opportunity to explore how green infrastructure projects are transforming the way we develop and repair our cities and towns.
As well as a key note Ministerial speech, during the day delegates will learn about three exciting projects which focus on the use of green infrastructure, innovation and liveability:
• Bosco Verticale in Milan
• Big Lottery Living Landmarks funded Connswater Community Greenway in east Belfast
• Copenhagen’s Gronne Cykeruter or Green Cycle Routes
TRAINING
Resourcing Scotland’s Heritage is delivering a series of training courses and events across Scotland.
Our training is best suited to registered charities and constituted community groups. Take a walk through our simple question and answer page to determine which course is right for you. We have two main training courses and a series of ‘In Focus’ events. If you are interested in any particular event or fundraising topic, please do get in touch – we may be able to bring an event to your area info@scotheritage.org.
Traditional Building Skills Training
Scottish Lime Centre Trust offer a wide range of vocational and professional courses combining theory and practical working sessions designed to ensure that there are courses to suit everyone.
VACANCIES
Digital Advisors South for Digital Towns Pilot Programme
Scotland’s Towns Partnership, in partnership with the Scottish Government, is seeking to appoint two digital advisors on a contract / project basis. The advisor / expert role is to deliver new collaborations and to provide advice around strategy, design, procurement, digital inclusion, and innovation in the context of Digital Towns. If you are interested in applying for this role, Scotland’s Towns Partnership would welcome a very short summary of your skills and expertise along with a fully inclusive day rate on the basis of between 20 – 40 days’ work. Please send your professional summary by 5pm, 28 April 2017 to Elaine Bone at: elaine@scotlandstowns.org.
Policy Adviser, Heritage Skills and Training
The Heritage Lottery Fund is recruiting for a Policy Adviser; Skills and Training to lead our strategic and policy work on heritage skills and training across the UK and manages HLF’s Skills for the Future grant programme. To be competitive in the role, you will need to demonstrate high level knowledge, skills and experience against our selection criteria.
Closing date for online applications will be Midnight Monday 1st May 2017 and interviews will be held in our London office on 8th of May 2017.
BEFS Director reflects on the built environment hustings held this month in Glasgow and Edinburgh.
In the last week Built Environment Forum Scotland has supported hustings in Glasgow and Edinburgh with a focus on the built environment in advance of the local government elections on the 4th May. The events were organised by locally based organisations, the New Glasgow Society and Edinburgh World Heritage. What did we learn at them?
All candidates declared their love for the heritage of the respective cities but the Edinburgh candidates were slightly more specific in also declaring support of the draft Edinburgh World Heritage Management Plan – reflecting the specific interest of the organisers. Across both events there was acknowledgement that things were not perfect, that communities needed to be listened to but also that local authorities were tied by budget cuts and lack of relevant powers on some issues.
Business Rates were a hot topic in Glasgow – but controlled by Scottish Government – and combined with retail unit management by City Property – with several councillors on the Board – came in for significant criticism. Land Value Tax was supported by some Glasgow candidates and affordable housing was also a shared priority. Candidates tended towards the general comment on existing policy and processes, wanting better building maintenance, use of compulsory purchase orders etc. but the SNP candidate specifically proposed a “city architect” and a “historic Glasgow zone”. Details on the role and power of the city architect are unclear and as was pointed out on Twitter, Glasgow already has a Central Conservation Area. You can follow some of the online Twitter commentary at #ngsqt, informed, illuminating and entertaining.
The Edinburgh hustings had a stronger focus on short term lets, and the perception of an over provision of hotel and student accommodation within the city centre. The candidates were united in acknowledging that the local authority does not currently have the powers to address the phenomenon of Airbnb and have asked The Scottish Parliament to legislate on it. There was a general acknowledgement that Edinburgh now had adequate hotel provision but some candidates wished to see hotels spread to the outskirts of the city. A similar tack was taken on student accommodation, that it needed to be spread rather than concentrated – the reality is that student accommodation has been opposed by communities wherever it has been proposed, central or suburban.
Both events became more heated as they progressed, Edinburgh quite significantly with a loud cheer for the audience member who said that the public had been betrayed by the City of Edinburgh Council. Councillors were asked why they should be voted for and the reply was ‘based on our record’: the absence of published voting records on council committees makes this rather difficult. Questions that remain unanswered were on how to improve building maintenance and whether local authorities retained enough conservation skills in-house.
Both events revealed the public passion for the built environment and the level of expertise available within communities. They also reveal the complexities of decision making and the lack of joined up thinking within local authorities which leads to the planning process becoming a focus for communities to express dissatisfaction with a wide range of issues not subject to planning legislation.
The Place Standard Tool is being increasingly adopted for community engagement and it seems that “influence and sense of control” frequently receives low scores. The audiences at these hustings were also clearly frustrated by this and while there is no quick fix to this within the current system, continuing local dialogue with the successful candidates is necessary and hopefully BEFS Advocacy Toolkit will provide a starter for those wishing to begin.
********
Further summaries of the Edinburgh hustings can be found from Edinburgh World Heritage, Cliff Hague and the Broughton Spurtle.
BACK
Graham Marchbank, a member of the Scottish Executive Committee of the RTPI, offers a great case study of how a community came together to rebuild a Victorian wall.
A group of residents in adjacent terraced streets in the Pilrig Conservation Area in Leith are now the satisfied owners of a safe and sound section of Victorian garden party-wall.
The wall was listing badly at about 11 degrees from the vertical and had started to collapse owing in part to structural weaknesses (Fig. 1).
Fig 1. Fig. 2

Research shows that:
Historically, building materials were largely selected based on what was available locally. For centuries prior to the widespread availability of lime, binders such as earth and clay were commonly used in Scotland. The use of these declined as they were superseded by lime, and then cement, in modern construction.
However when the section of this wall was brought down, it was evident that soil had been used as an inferior construction binder (Fig. 2) rather than lime mortar, probably in the 1890s when the houses were built on land assigned from the Balfour Estate. The soil all had to be carted away along with any rotted or degraded sandstone (deeds from the 1890s state that the stone for the houses came from Clunievar Quarry just west of Dunfermline) unsuitable for reuse.
Following demolition by hand, stone by stone, the wall was rebuilt in a traditional style (Fig. 3). The middle of the wall was filled in with smaller stones then a quicklime slurry was poured over them to bind them in (Fig. 4), giving additional strength.
Fig. 3 Fig. 4

Pointing was “knocked back” while still damp to provide a smart finish (Fig. 5). Existing stone was used where possible along with sandstone recovered from another job at one of the properties.
Fig. 5 Fig. 6

Finally the wall was topped out with the original coping stones (Fig. 6), kept damp under sackcloth to set for a couple of days, and the job was done.
Contractor:
Muir Stone Repair, summer 2016.
BACK
Get The Latest Historic Environment Events, Jobs, News And Publications In BEFS Bulletin.
BEFS NEWS
Last week BEFS hosted its annual conference, Financing the Historic Environment, in Glasgow, in collaboration with The Prince’s Regeneration Trust and Heritage Lottery Fund Scotland. To find out more, view the insightful and colourful presentations from a wide range of speakers who contributed to the conference across the two days. Furthermore, Joaquin Basile Patron from Prince’s Regeneration Trust reflects on his impressions of the conference in our blog this week.
Responding to the consultation on the future of the Scottish Planning system, BEFS has highlighted the need for a more evidence-led approach. Read the full submission here. A number of BEFS members’ also responded to the consultation and you can read their submissions on our policy topics page on Planning.
In the run up to the local government elections in May, BEFS is supporting two hustings on the built environment. The first, Architecture and Planning – A Hustings for Glasgow’s Built Environment, is organised by New Glasgow Society and will take place on 12th April at the Lighthouse in Glasgow. The second event will take place on World Heritage Day 2017. Edinburgh World Heritage will be hosting a ‘Heritage Hustings’ in Stockbridge, Edinburgh. They offer an opportunity for the general public to question the candidates on the heritage and built environment issues you feel strongly about. Both events are free but registration via the Eventbrite pages is recommended.
For tips on how to engage with your local candidates ahead of the elections, including who to contact and how, how to make the case for the built environment and useful facts and figures, check out BEFS Advocacy Toolkit. HES’s designated assets tool, which enables you to search for designations by council ward area, may also prove useful when discussing the local impact of the historic environment with politicians.
Finally, we would like to draw your attention to both the Cockburn Association’s Civic Agenda and Scottish Civic Trust’s 6 Point Action Plan ahead of the local elections (under Publications).
CONSULTATIONS
The Scottish Parliament’s Local Government and Communities Committee has today, Tuesday 4 April, launched a call for written evidence on City Region Deals and local growth deals.
The closing date for receipt of submissions is Tuesday 2 May 2017. Guidance on Engaging Communities in Decisions Relating to Land (SG 24/03/17)
Under Part 4 of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016 (“the Act”), Scottish Ministers have a duty to issue “guidance about engaging communities in decisions relating to land which may affect communities” (“the Guidance”). The consultation seeks the views of key stakeholders on the draft Guidance.
Closes 16 Jun 2017.
CONSULTATION RESPONSES
Summary of responses and government response to the permission in principle and brownfield registers chapters of the technical consultation on planning changes
Latest quarterly statistics on planning applications decided in October to December 2016 show that the average decision time for local developments was three days slower than the previous quarter, but one day faster than the equivalent quarter in the previous year.A Civic Agenda for Edinburgh (Cockburn Association 03/04/17)
The Cockburn Association has published a Civic Agenda ahead of the local council elections next month. The agenda recognises that Edinburgh is growing and will continue to grow, but asserts that it is essential that growth is managed in ways that enhance the qualities of the city.
Scottish Social Housing Charter April 2017 (SG 28/03/17)
The first Charter came into effect on 1 April 2012 and was reviewed during 2016. This revised Charter was approved by Parliament and has effect from 1 April 2017.
6-Point Action Plan (SCT 24/03/17)
The Scottish Civic Trust has issued a six-point action plan for the new administrations of Scotland’s local authorities after the May elections.
Scotland strengthens commitment in response to Paris Agreement. A joint agreement committing the Scottish Government and the Government of California to work together to tackle climate change has been signed today.£30 million announced to help makes homes warmer (SG 03/04/17)
Interest-free loans now available to help reduce fuel bills. The Scottish Government’s Home Energy Efficiency Programme Scotland (HEEPS) has announced £30 million of funding to help householders make their homes more energy efficient.
Crown Estate Scotland (SG 01/04/17)
Control of multi-million pound assets will benefit local communities. Powers over the revenue and management of Crown Estate resources in Scotland have been transferred to the Scottish Government, giving communities a stronger voice in how these assets are managed.
£16m for affordable housing (SG 30/03/17)
Investment in new homes to rent for Shetland, Borders and Fife. Affordable housing in Shetland, Borders and Fife has received a boost of £16 million this month thanks to Scottish Government investment in charitable bonds.
UK housing benefit changes ‘shameful’ (SG 26/03/17)
Support for young people at risk of being pushed into homelessness. More young people in Scotland will be at risk of homelessness due to UK Government changes to housing benefit, Social Security Secretary Angela Constance has said.
The European Commission and Europa Nostra revealed today the winners of the 2017 European Union Prize for Cultural Heritage / Europa Nostra Awards, Europe’s top honour in the heritage field.New-look Saltire Civil Engineering Awards launched (ICE 04/04/17)
All professions working in the built environment are invited to nominate projects or project phases located in Scotland and substantially completed in 2016/17. The Saltire Civil Engineering Awards celebrate outstanding civil engineering achievement, innovation and ingenuity in Scotland and have grown into the highest honour for engineering excellence in the built environment.The closing date for submissions will be 4pm on Friday 12 May, 2017.
Are City Region Deals worth the headlines, asks Committee (SP 04/04/17)
The Local Government and Communities Committee is looking for a variety of opinions from organisations and members of the public on the purpose of City and Region Deals, whether they are working for communities and how they are being run.
New measures to unlock brownfield land for thousands of homes (DCLG 03/04/17)
Councils will have new tools to speed up development of derelict and underused land for new homes, Housing and Planning Minister Gavin Barwell confirmed today (3 April 2017). Local authorities across the country will now have to produce and maintain up-to-date, publicly available registers of brownfield sites available for housing locally.
Romans, Picts, Steampunks and Guerrilla Knitters to Celebrate Scotland’s Six Iconic Sites (SoAoS 30/03/17)
Scotland’s six World Heritage Sites will be celebrated with six coordinated events for the first time on World Heritage Day.
Great Place Scheme Scotland (HLF Scotland 29/03/17)
“The Great Place scheme is a challenge to local leaders to work together to put culture right at the centre of their local plans.” – HLF Chief Executive, Ros Kerslake.
Recently launched in Scotland, the Great Place Scheme has been designed by HLF and partners to ensure intelligent investment in place-based regeneration. It offers funding for greater collaboration between cultural, community and civic organisations in tackling issues such as poverty and inequality, employment, education and health. With grants of £100,000 to £1m to support applicants in piloting new, more effective ways of working together, the Great Place Scheme includes everything from city-wide initiatives to smaller, rural schemes.
Royal High School Statement March 2017 (HES 28/03/17)
A statement of our position on the former Royal High School in Edinburgh.
Celebrate YHHA with MyParkScotland (greenspace Scotland 28/03/17)
MyParkScotland is Scotland’s only greenspace crowdfunding platform and on 26 April we’ll launch a History, Heritage and Archaeology project campaign theme to support groups looking for funding. If your organisation is looking for funding for a history or heritage project in your local park or greenspace then this campaign is for you. Being part of the theme will raise profile and increase coverage and donations to your project. Creating a “buzz” around the theme #myparkheritage will allow for better promotion, social media and press both locally and nationally. We are organising a training session for projects taking part on 19th April in Glasgow. To find out more contact Ian Goodman on 01786 849 757 or ian.goodman@mypark.scot.
Edinburgh Castle named 16th most visited UK attraction (HES 27/03/17)
Scotland’s top paid for visitor attraction, Edinburgh Castle, has jumped up two places in the rankings to be named as the 16th most visited attraction in the UK in 2016. Footfall at the historic site exceeded 1.7 million visitors, a 13% increase on 2015.
Climate Change Hat Trick for HES (HES 24/03/17)
Historic Environment Scotland (HES) has been awarded the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) Scotland Public Body Champion Award for the third year in a row in recognition of its work to tackle climate change, it was announced today (Friday 24 March).
Planning Places Survey (Young Scott xx/03/17)
As part of the Scottish Government’s consultation on Places, People and Planning they have asked Young Scot to run a survey aimed at seeking views on how the places where children and young people live, work or go to school should change in the future.
IHBC Guidance Note ‘Community Infrastructure Levy and Historic Buildings’ online (IHBC 22/03/17)
IHBC’s Guidance Note (GN), ‘Community Infrastructure Levy and Historic Buildings’ has been published on the IHBC’s Toolbox. Bob Kindred, IHBC Research co-ordinator and author of this Guidance Note, said: ‘This Guidance Note looks at some examples of current practice regarding the use of (or exemption from) the Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) with regard to heritage assets.
STBF Featured in Scottish Parliament Answer (STBF 21/03/17)
There are real concerns about the lack of skills tradespeople in the traditional building sector and the Scottish Traditional Building Forum has been extremely active in educational engagement with schools and pupils to raise the profile of the careers available.
STBF Featured in Focus Magazine 2017 (STBF 21/03/17)
The activities of the Scottish Traditional Building Forum across Scotland were featured in this year’s Historic Environment Scotland Focus Magazine (page 54, we are not quite hold the front page yet).
SAH Announces Public Programming at Glasgow Conference (SAH 17/03/17)
The Society of Architectural Historians (SAH) will present a Mackintosh Symposium, public architecture tours and a seminar on heritage and sustainability as part of its 70th Annual International Conference to be held in Glasgow, June 7–11. These public programmes are designed to provide a platform for conference delegates from around the world to celebrate and study the conference’s host city and engage with the local community.
PAS submitted a response to the consultation, informed by input from our policy group, public workshops and our volunteer network. The following is a quick overview of some of the key points made in our response.RTPI Scotland: Scotland needs a clearer national development roadmap (RTPI 04/04/17)
Planners have called on the Scottish Government to establish national development priorities across Scotland and map them out clearly in a new National Development Plan (NDP).
Scottish Awards for Quality in Planning 2017 (PAS 31/03/17)
PAS is pleased to be supporting the Scottish Awards for Quality in Planning #SAQP2017, assisting again in assessing the community engagement aspect of the submitted entries. The awards celebrate achievements in planning, from the detail of processing to the bigger picture. Applications are open until 19 May.
RIAS/ RIBA Awards Scotland – 2017 Shortlist Announced (RIAS 29/03/17)
The Royal Incorporation of Architects in Scotland (RIAS) are pleased to announce a 27 strong shortlist for the 2017 awards.
My Place Award Winners 2017 (SCT 23/03/17)
The winning and commended projects in the Scottish Civic Trust My Place Awards 2017 were announced today, 23 March, by Kevin Stewart, Minister for Local Government and Housing and Colin McLean, SCT Chairman, in The Lighthouse, Glasgow.
RTPI Awards for Research Excellence 2017 (RTPI xx/03/17)
The RTPI Awards for Research Excellence recognise and promote high quality, impactful spatial planning research from RTPI accredited planning schools, and planning consultancies, in the UK, the Republic of Ireland and internationally. The Awards are now open for entries. Entries must be sent electronically to research@rtpi.org.uk by Friday 19th May 2017.
Questions marked with a triangle (?) are initiated by the Scottish Government in order to facilitate the provision of information to the Parliament.Questions in which a member has indicated a declarable interest are marked with an “R”.
S5W-08476 Christine Grahame: To ask the Scottish Government what measures are in place to permit the compulsory purchase of vacant commercial premises in town centres for the purpose of redeveloping them for social housing. (SP 30/03/17)
S5W-08477 Christine Grahame: To ask the Scottish Government what measures are in place to require an assessment of services, such as schools, public transport and medical facilities, to take place as a condition of planning consents for housing developments. (SP 30/03/17)
Questions marked with a triangle (?) are initiated by the Government in order to facilitate the provision of information to the Parliament.
Question S5W-08101: Neil Findlay, Lothian, Scottish Labour, Date Lodged: 14/03/2017.
To ask the Scottish Government when it will next review what is included in home reports.
Answered by Kevin Stewart (22/03/2017)
Question S5W-07841: Jackson Carlaw, Eastwood, Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Date Lodged: 07/03/2017.
To ask the Scottish Government when it will respond to the recommendations in the five-year review of the Home Report.
Answered by Kevin Stewart (16/03/2017)
• 1 to 16 April 2017 (inclusive)
• 1 July to 3 September 2017 (inclusive)
For the latest information about BEFS Members’ events see our events calendar.
European Heritage & Cultural Identity
When: Thursday, 13 April 2017 from 17:30 – 20:30.
Where: Edinburgh College of Art, Main Lecture Theatre, 74 Lauriston Place, Edinburgh EH3 9DF.
An open seminar on our shared European tangible and intangible heritage featuring: John Lowrey, University of Edinburgh, Robert Belot, Université Bourgogne Franche-Comté, UTBM, Roel During, Alterra/Wageningen University, Radu Albu Comanescu, Universitatea ‘Babes-Bolyai’ Cluj-Napoca Klausenburg, and Laurier Turgeon, Laboratoire d’enquête ethnologique et multimedia. Entry: £5 towards costs; free to Edinburgh World Heritage members.
2017 Heritage Hustings
When: 18 April 2017 from 6pm-8pm
Where: Saint Stephen’s Stockbridge, Saint Stephen Street, Edinburgh EH3 5AB.
For World Heritage Day 2017, Edinburgh World Heritage will be hosting the city’s first ever ‘Heritage Hustings’ against the backdrop of Playfair’s majestic St. Stephen’s Church. This is your chance to question the candidates on the heritage issues you feel strongly about such as the contribution of new development to the city, the care and maintenance of historic buildings, issues of planning control, and the balance between the needs of visitors and residents.
Supported by Built Environment Forum Scotland
AHSS Strathclyde Group AGM
When: 22 April 10:30 – 13:00.
Where: St Columbkille’s Church, 2 Kirkwood St, Rutherglen, Glasgow G73 2SL.
Cost: £10 (attendance at the AGM is free and the costs relate to donations, lunches and gratuities)
The meeting will take place in the church hall and will be followed by a guided tour. St Columbkille’s is a category A listed church designed by Jack Coia of Gillespie, Kidd & Coia and was completed in 1940. The church has recently undergone an extensive two phased conservation and repair project to both the exterior and the interior led by Mr Brian A. Park of Page/Park Architects. The tour will be conducted by Hamish Macbeth who was also involved with the project.
AHSS Dumfries and Galloway Group event
When: 29 April 14:15 – 16:15.
Where: Gordon Memorial Hall, St. Ninian’s Episcopal Church, Whitepark Road, Castle Douglas, Kirkcudbrightshire, DG7 1EX.
Cost: Free
‘Forgotten Railways of Dumfries and Galloway’ by Angus Rex of the Scottish Railway Preservation Society (SRPS).
Scottish Civic Trust Annual Lecture 2017
When: Tue 25 April 2017 from 17:30 – 19:30.
Where: Scottish Storytelling Centre, 43-45 High Street, Edinburgh EH1 1SR.
Merchant City, one of Glasgow’s most historic areas has experienced many changes in its time, so much so that on more than one occasion it almost disappeared from the face of the earth. Its renaissance in more recent years has become part of the city’s folklore – but the story is not over yet! We will explore how we arrived at the present, and look at some of the issues for the future.
This lecture by architect and historian David Martin is part of a series of events which celebrate, in 2017, the 50th anniversary of both the inaugural meeting of the Scottish Civic Trust and the passing of the Civic Amenities Act 1967 which introduced the concept of conservation areas.
Scottish Civic Trust is celebrating its 50th anniversary
Since 1967 the Trust has been at the forefront of celebrating and protecting Scotland’s historic environment, promoting good modern architecture, and engaging with local communities and the general public through a wide range of activities. The Scottish Civic Trust will be partnering with Glasgow City Heritage Trust to deliver a short series of events with a focus on Glasgow’s heritage, built, cultural and intangible. All events start at 7pm and are held at GCHT Offices at 54 Bell Street:
- Tobacco Merchants and Shipbuilders – Michael Hannon with an introduction by John Pelan
- Glasgow’s Cinema Experiment, Gordon Barr and Gary Painte
- Debate: Conservation vs. Evolution
When: Tuesday 9th May 5.30-7pm.
Where: Tranent Town Hall, Church Street, Tranent.
Vital information will be provided to help you:
• Find out the condition of your property
• Find out the process required to repair and maintain your property
• Learn what funding options are available to you
• Talks from professionals who can start you on the right track
• Q&A opportunity at help desks
Why not come along to this free event. If you would like to attend please BOOK YOUR PLACE rsvp to: conservation@hypostyle.co.ukMore Conservation Challenges – RIAS Spring Seminar
When: 31 May 2017; 13.00 to 17.00.
Where: The Scottish Storytelling Centre, Edinburgh
Cost: RIAS accredited members and members of Practice Services: £22 inc. VAT. RIAS member: £28 inc. VAT. Non-members: £40 inc. VAT
The RIAS conservation spring seminar is now open for bookings. Topics will include conservation work at the Capitol, Washington DC, and the Scottish architectural legacy in India. The technical components will include climate change adaptation for traditional buildings, interpreting thermal imaging and advice on working with lime for pointing and harling, including specification advice and guidance on the causes of failure, 3D laser scanning technique as used in the restoration of Glasgow School of Art. For programme and booking form click here. If you wish to book a place, please complete a booking form and email to Hayley.Kyle@rias.org.uk
Scottish Waterways Trust are looking for someone who can develop and deliver innovative programmes of education, engagement and practical heritage conservation tasks across Scotland’s canal network. Working with children, young people, volunteers and the general public we need someone who can enthuse and motivate people and connect them with the heritage of our canals.
You’ll be able to plan, co-ordinate, deliver and evaluate a range of public events, volunteering days, schools activities, walks, talks and more which help people to learn about, and care for, Scotland’s unique canal heritage. You’ll have experience in delivering programmes to our target groups, be able to build strong relationships with a wide range of key stakeholders and will have a good knowledge of cultural heritage and be skilled in conservation tasks. Travel is an essential part of this role and the post-holder is required to deliver activities in the Highlands and Lowlands, with an office base in Falkirk.
Closing date: Midday on Thursday 13th April.
Joaquin Basile Patron, Communications Intern at Prince’s Regeneration Trust, reflects on his impressions of BEFS two-day conference, Financing the Historic Environment.
On the 29 and 30 of March 2017, I attended the conference Financing the Historic Environment organized by Built Environment Forum Scotland, Heritage Lottery Fund Scotland and the BRICK (Building Resources, Investment & Community Knowledge) programme run by The Prince’s Regeneration Trust (PRT) where I currently work.
As a communications intern from Uruguay who has lived in London for less than two months, my background in heritage is limited, making the chance to be a part of this conference a great opportunity for increasing my understanding of relevant issues within the heritage field. Before I attended this conference, I did not know how heritage projects managed to obtain funding, and I was curious to discover the different processes that organizations must go through to achieve their goals. Listening to all the presentations and interviewing some of the key people at this conference allowed me to understand that finding funding for heritage projects can be a struggle, but with determination and community engagement, it is not impossible and, indeed, there are many success stories.
Different methods to achieve financial goals were successfully explored in both days of Financing the Historic Environment. On day one, a main topic discussed was “Commercial Investment in the Historic Environment,” which guided participants to better understand this alternative method for obtaining funds for project development. Representatives from Scottish Property Federation, Trevor Osborne Property Group and the Royal Bank of Scotland examined the risk factors behind investing in a historic building. Although the speakers initially established a slightly pessimistic scenario for historic buildings by agreeing on the greater economic appeal of modern buildings, they did share hope for those who intended to restore heritage sites. When an audience member enquired on how to address some of the given risks, the speakers agreed that, although the lack of flexibility and lower-level efficiency of historic buildings represent a risk to investors, the negative impact of these factors might be decreased through community engagement, increasing a project’s chances for funding.
On day two, I was able to understand the benefits of tourism on the preservation of historic treasures. On the section “Heritage Tourism Investment” Jana Hutt from Knockando Woolmill, Martin Hulse from Dunston Staiths and Paul Higson from Portsoy Sail Loft discussed their work on projects that were meant to attract tourism. Although combining touristic activity and historic buildings can be a challenging task, these speakers emphasized how a deep knowledge of a heritage project can benefit the project’s outcomes. When an attendee asked about the importance of collaboration among different heritage projects, Ms. Hutt argued that it is important to collaborate with other local projects to achieve better results. Day two also provided examples of success stories to help inspire delegates who are working on similar projects.
Overall, “Financing the Historic Environment” was a huge success, trending locally on Twitter (with #HeritageFinance) and with great attendance both on 29th and 30th of March. Personally, this conference has taught the difficulties for some projects to reach completion but also how rewarding it is for all those who were involved every step of the way. The tools provided by each speaker will hopefully encourage the preservation of other historic buildings that are significant to the history of the United Kingdom and that have the potential to provide new jobs and revive a local community. The diversity of the speakers presenting at Financing the Historic Environment further elevated this event by exposing me and the rest of the attendees to the benefits (and challenges) of obtaining both public and private funding and by providing insights into different heritage projects. Events such as Financing the Historic Environment share BRICK’s goals of supporting community groups that are trying to create a better future for their local area by saving their heritage sites. I believe that these kinds of events can be meaningful for communities and lead to new projects. I sincerely hope that more collaborations among heritage organizations happen in the future to preserve, what I see to be, one of the biggest parts of the UK’s culture.
BACK
Insightful and colourful presentations from a range of speakers who contributed to BEFS two-day conference in Glasgow.
2017 is the Year of History Heritage and Archaeology, a celebration of what gives Scotland its unique character and draws people to live, work and visit. Caring for these assets is a collaborative effort across the United Kingdom undertaken by a wide range of organisations, from voluntary community groups to large-scale commercial development, public bodies and local and national government.
These are challenging times for public sector budgets and while the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act creates the potential for transfer of historic assets to communities there remains a need for the commercial sector to invest in historic places. In a changing economic landscape, an era of rapid technological advancement and the need to mitigate the challenges of climate change there is no escape from the historic environment’s need for increased investment.
What are the challenges faced by the investment community in developing historic buildings? How does grant aided investment lever in additional funding and stimulate economic activity? How can local authority and public body asset management make the most of the historic environment? What makes small scale tourist sites financially viable? How are national heritage organisations approaching investment in their portfolios? How can the heritage sector help overcome any barriers?
BEFS two-day conference, organised in collaboration with Heritage Lottery Fund Scotland and the BRICK programme run by The Prince’s Regeneration Trust, explored these questions and how local communities can be at the heart of solutions. To find out more, view the presentations of our wide range of speakers across the two days:
DAY ONE
Commercial Investment in the Historic Environment
- Paul Curran, Scottish Property Federation
- Robert Moore, Trevor Osborne Property Group
- Stuart Heslop, Royal Bank of Scotland
Local Investment
- Sarah Kettles, Conservation Area Regeneration Scheme
- Alan Lodge, Townscape Heritage Initiative
- Robin Webster, Glasgow City Heritage Trust
Keynote
Heritage Asset Management
- Richard Cairns, West Dunbartonshire Council
- Stewart Adams, NHS
- Gary Brown, Brymbo Heritage Group
Keynote
- Ian Marcus, The Prince’s Regeneration Trust
DAY TWO
Heritage Tourism Investment
- Jana Hutt, Knockando Woolmill
- Martin Hulse, Dunston Staiths
- Paul Higson, Portsoy Sail Loft
Keynote
Access to Funding
- Oluwaseun Soyemi, Heritage Enterprise
- Gordon Barr, Architectural Heritage Fund
- Ailsa Raeburn, Scottish Land Fund
Funding the National Collections
- Bryan Dickson, National Trust for Scotland
- David Mitchell, Historic Environment Scotland
Keynote
- Scott McCauley, New Lanark Trust
List of delegates who attended the conference.
BACK










